Home » today » World » Ohio judge declares mistrial in case of ex-cop accused of murdering woman in prostitution sting operation

Ohio judge declares mistrial in case of ex-cop accused of murdering woman in prostitution sting operation


It is not yet known whether prosecutors will retry Mitchell, who faces life in prison if convicted of the crime.

Photo: Daniel Bone / Pixabay

An Ohio state jury was unable to determine the guilt or innocence of a former Columbus police officer accused of killing a woman while working undercover, prompting the judge to declare a mistrial.

The ruling came after the members of the jury did not reach a unanimous decision after 10 hours of deliberation in three days, in the case of Andrew Mitchell, who is charged with murder and voluntary manslaughter in the death of 23-year-old Donna Castleberry.which he said was a prostitution bust, WTTW-TV reported.

Ten witnesses testified at the trial, including former officer Mitchell himself.

The jury began deliberations last Wednesday and informed Franklin County Court Judge David Young that the panel was deadlocked.

Seven jurors found the former official’s use of force reasonable, while two others found it unreasonable and three were undecided in their decision, NBC4 said.

It is not yet known whether prosecutors will retry Mitchell, who faces life in prison if convicted of the crime.

“The State of Ohio will carefully review all available options to finalize this matter and will make a public announcement within seven days,” Franklin County District Attorney Gary Tyack said in a statement.

Mitchell is in federal custody in another case in which he allegedly forced women to have sex with him in exchange for avoiding arrest. That case was not shared with the jury.

Following Castleberry’s murder, the Columbus Division of Police abolished its vice unit.

After the mistrial was declared, the department released a statement saying several changes were made, including a mandate that officers never work alone, that stops by request are always made by a uniformed officer in a marked patrol car.

Also read:

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.