What happened
Rostov beat RPL leader Spartak 1: 0 in Moscow. Karpin’s team defended the required score, even despite the fact that the referee Vitaly Meshkov at the 75th minute in a controversial moment showed the second yellow center-back of “Rostov” Dennis Hadzhikadunich.
After the match, Valery Karpin performed as best he could:
“So much has been said about the referees… We can talk about it after every game, and after every game it will be the same. Anyone can say: we, Spartak, someone else. Here you (addresses to the correspondent of “Match TV” Mikhail Mossakovsky. – Sport24) Didn’t you watch the highlights of the referee who judged us from Sochi? Who removed Norman? He judged “Chertanovo” (we are talking about the match of the 18th round of the FNL “Chertanovo” – “Chaika” – 1: 2, in which the referee Evgeniy Turbin did not appoint 3 obvious penalties to the hosts’ goal. – Sport24)… Take a look at this thread – these three penalties. A man is standing five meters away, and it does not whistle!
Why say something after that? Why ask someone something? A man judges the Premier League – and he does this ?! I don’t even know what word to choose here. And the point is to talk about it? They should be ashamed of the fact that they have such people, ”Karpin said on the air of the Match Premier TV channel.
What are the claims of Karpina Turbin
Indeed, in the match of the 10th round “Sochi” – “Rostov” (4: 2), Evgeny Turbin sent off Matthias Normann from the field in the 63rd minute. Moreover, he showed the Norwegian a second yellow card because he was emotionally indignant after a hard tackle by Christian Noboa, who was also shown a yellow card by the referee. After the final whistle, Karpin also received red.
After that game, Karpin harshly criticized the Russian judges. Answering the question about how to deal with the referee scandals in the RPL, which occur almost after every round, Karpin said: “There is a way out. Punish harshly! “
“Suspend from work?” – asked him.
“But here you also need to understand how many matches and how to do it,” Karpin answered. – Demotion to the FNL is not a suspension. The same thing happens there. “
Karpin noted that one of the options could be a complete suspension from refereeing for a certain time. The coach of “Rostov” also expressed the opinion that in the match “Sochi” – “Rostov” there was an unequivocal referee bias.
What match was Karpin talking about
The expert referee commission considered that Turbin had grounds for removing Norman and Karpin, but in the end the referee was suspended from the RPL matches for two rounds. But Turbin reminded of himself even in the FNL. In the match “Chertanovo” – “Chaika” he did not assign three obvious penalties to the hosts’ goal. “The Seagull” even posted a video clip with controversial episodes.
Former judge, founder of the telegram channel “Ale, ref!” Ilya Oblomov analyzed all three episodes:
“The first moment is hand play. Here you need to watch the video not “Seagulls” (there the white ball merges with the shield and it is not visible whether the player is playing the ball). The video from another angle shows that the player in white plays the ball, then it hits the hand. If a player deliberately plays the ball with his head or foot and after that the ball hits the hand (it does not matter if it is in its natural position or not), then it is worth continuing the game. These are the current interpretations of the Laws of the Game. My verdict is that the arbiter is right to continue playing.
The second moment is Chochiev’s fall after the step of the Chertanovo player. Chochiev is the first on the ball, the defender does not have time to play the ball and knocks down the player of “Seagull”. The referee made a mistake by not ordering a penalty kick. Should have awarded a penalty without showing a yellow card – this is a negligent foul.
The third moment is Umaev’s fall in the penalty area of ”Chertanovo”. The Seagull striker is the first on the ball, Abaev knocks down the player, acting in a reckless manner. It was necessary to appoint a 11-meter kick with a yellow card for rough play, the referee made a mistake, continuing the game.
Interestingly, Turbin was already at the center of the scandal after the game “Chertanovo”. We are talking about the match of the Moscow Championship among the teams born in 2003 “Chertanovo” – “Khimki” (6: 0). The referee appointed four 11-meter shots to the guests’ goal. The commission recognized Turbin’s refereeing as biased due to the wrong appointment of three 11-meters. The Moscow Football Federation suspended Turbin from refereeing for a year – it was after this that Evgeny moved to the Moscow Region Football Federation, since in order to receive a recommendation for the season, RPL referees need to serve at least 10 games at Moscow competitions. “
Effects
“Chaika” has already sent a request to the referee commission of the RFU, and the general director of “Chaika” Maxim Ponomarev said that the club demands respect from the referee.
“We have no right to leave what we saw in the last round without comment, even though the outcome of the meeting was successful for Chaika. Please be informed that we have sent an official request to the RFU Expert Judicial Commission. We sincerely want to understand what determined the decisions of the most experienced referee Evgeny Turbin in our match against Chertanovo, – said Ponomarev.
Even the general director of Baltika, Tazhutdin Kachukaev, made a speech, saying that Turbin made mistakes in the Chertanovo – Chaika match deliberately.
“At first I did not attach any importance to the refereeing of this match, but I was asked to watch the game episodes. I declare with full responsibility that the referee’s mistakes are deliberate! He either swam from the heat of the game, or he was promised a “golden” parachute from the inhabitants of heaven. It is not normal. If we ignore this, we will sink into a dirty swamp, ”Kachukaev said.
Download Sport24 app for Android
– .
