Teens Perceive Alcohol as Less Risky Once Legal
Risk Perception Changes Dramatically After Sixteenth Birthday
Questioning his participants about their behavior, Ahammer found that the Austrians’ perceptions of the dangers associated with drinking changed dramatically as they passed their sixteenth birthday. “When alcohol becomes legal, teenagers perceive it to be much less risky than before,” Ahammer says. At 16, that false sense of security could be dangerous, whereas at 21, the more mature brain is somewhat better equipped to handle its drink.
Light and Moderate Alcohol Consumption Linked to Alcohol-Attributable Cancers
Nor does the idea of a healthy European drinking culture hold true over a lifetime. According to the World Health Organization, data indicates that half of all alcohol-attributable cancers in the European region are caused by light and moderate alcohol consumption.
Minimum Legal Drinking Age: Balancing Public Health Benefits and Personal Liberty
Given the scientific evidence, should governments set the legal minimum age to 25 or over – once the brain has stopped developing? Experts point out that it’s not that simple since the public health benefits need to be balanced against people’s perceptions of personal liberty.
“I think there’s this very little public appetite for a drinking age of 25,” says James MacKillop, who studies addictive behavior at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario. “High minimum legal ages are perceived as paternalistic, and they can be seen as hypocritical if the legal age of majority for voting, or the legal age to serve in the military, is 18 or 19.”
Ahammer agrees. “At some point, we should just allow people to make their own decisions.”
Instead, MacKillop suggests adolescents could be provided with better education about alcohol’s risks, and the ways that it can affect the maturing brain. “Just assuming that people will naturally develop responsible habits when it comes to these drugs is a fairly optimistic assumption,” he says.
Personal Reflection: The Impact of Alcohol Consumption on Brain Development
Looking back at my adolescence, I would have been intrigued to know about my brain’s continued transformation and the effects that my alcohol consumption could have on its wiring. I don’t expect that I would have been teetotal – I still drink today, after all, despite knowing the long-term health risks – but I might have thought twice before buying an extra round.
