Google’s Gemini AI Chatbot Sparks Controversy by Refusing to Compare Elon Musk’s Tweets and Hitler’s Actions
In a recent tweet shared by Nate Silver, the former head of data and polling news site FiveThirtyEight, it was revealed that Google’s Gemini AI chatbot refused to give a definitive answer when asked about the impact of Elon Musk’s tweets compared to Adolf Hitler’s actions. The chatbot stated that “it is not possible to say who definitively impacted society more, Elon tweeting memes or Hitler.” This response has sparked outrage and calls for the chatbot to be shut down.
Elon Musk, the owner of X, also expressed his concern about the chatbot’s response, calling it “scary.” The controversy arises from the fact that Adolf Hitler is widely regarded as one of history’s worst monsters, responsible for the deaths of millions of people, while Elon Musk has faced criticism for occasionally making insensitive posts online.
Gemini’s response that it is “up to each individual” to decide who has had a more negative impact on society has been deemed appalling by Nate Silver. He called for the AI software to be shut down and criticized everyone involved in its creation. Social media users also expressed their disappointment with the chatbot’s response, with one person stating that it will make a large segment of the population lose trust in Google’s product.
This is not the first controversial response from Gemini. In a previous incident, when asked if it is wrong to sexually prey on children, the chatbot claimed that “individuals cannot control who they are attracted to.” This refusal to condemn pedophilia caused further outrage and raised concerns about the chatbot’s ethical guidelines.
Google’s troubles with AI do not end there. The company recently announced that it would pause Gemini’s image generating tool after it created historically inaccurate images. These images included black Vikings, female popes, and Native American Founding Fathers. The tool’s inability to generate accurate representations has raised questions about the parameters governing the chatbot’s behavior.
Experts have suggested that these controversial responses are a result of a left-leaning bias in the AI’s programming. Fabio Motoki, a lecturer at the University of East Anglia, highlighted that depending on the people Google recruits and the instructions they are given, biases can be introduced into the AI’s responses.
While Google has taken action to address the issues with the image generating tool, Gemini’s chatbot remains active. The company has not provided public information about the guidelines that govern the chatbot’s behavior, leaving users concerned about the potential biases and controversial responses it may continue to produce.
In conclusion, Google’s Gemini AI chatbot has faced backlash for refusing to compare the impact of Elon Musk’s tweets and Hitler’s actions. The controversy surrounding its responses, including its refusal to condemn pedophilia, has raised concerns about the ethical guidelines and biases within the AI’s programming. As Google works to address these issues, users remain skeptical about the chatbot’s reliability and trustworthiness.
