UK Government Loses Bid to Keep Apple Surveillance Order Secret
“Today’s judgment is a victory for transparency,” said Akiko Hart, Director of Liberty, after the UK government lost its bid on Thursday to keep an Apple surveillance order secret.
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled against the Home Office, which had argued it should neither confirm nor deny that it issued a technical capability notice (TCN) to Apple — an order that would have forced the iPhone maker to share encrypted data.
The tribunal found the Home Office’s national security assessment “flawed in the public law sense”. Because the notice’s existence was already widely known — retrievable through a simple Google chatbot query — confirming it in court posed no new risk, the tribunal held.
The ruling matters for an estimated 39 to 40 million people in the UK who use iCloud, according to figures from consumer group Which? cited by Liberty. End-to-end encryption scrambles user data so no one else can read it, protecting bank details, health records, private messages and images.
“The public deserve to know when the government’s actions undermine their privacy and safety, and we welcome the Tribunal’s decision, which will shine more light on these secretive powers,” said Hart.”
A secret order, now confirmed
The government issued Apple with a TCN under the Investigatory Powers Act — legislation dubbed the “snooper’s charter” — which allows the Home Secretary to force tech companies to provide access to encrypted data. Companies that receive such notices are legally barred from disclosing them.

Until now, the government had neither confirmed nor denied the order’s existence. Liberty says the ruling has forced it to confirm the notice for the first time, though the specific technical details of the TCN remain secret.
Apple refused to build a backdoor into its systems, arguing that weakening encryption for UK users would compromise security worldwide. It also removed its advanced data protection (ADP) feature from the UK amid the dispute.
Leaks that sank the argument
A central problem for the Home Office was press coverage itself. On Thursday, the tribunal criticised “authorised leaks” to The Times and The Financial Times confirming the order, saying they fatally undermined the government’s claim that official confirmation would harm national security.
Home Office witnesses said leak investigations into the media articles found no government source. The tribunal noted the department produced no investigation reports, no details of steps taken, and no ministerial witness statements denying authorisation of the briefings.
The judgment also revealed that the UK government permitted Apple to inform the US Vice President and Attorney General while forbidding them from briefing Congress, and points to public statements by former US Representative Tulsi Gabbard claiming the UK momentarily relented before delivering a new order.
A second order after the first collapsed
This is the second round. After the initial notice last year, Apple brought a legal case to the tribunal, one anticipated to be heard in the early part of this year once the tribunal turned down the Home Secretary’s bid to conduct it wholly behind closed doors. That case was abandoned after diplomatic pushback from Washington led the Home Office to withdraw the global order.
The fresh notice followed. Apple filed its current challenge in August, and the hearing took place on September 17.
In parallel, Liberty and Privacy International — along with two individuals — are challenging the government’s power to issue TCNs at all. At a case management hearing in September 2026, the groups argued the “neither confirm nor deny” stance should be rejected so the case could proceed on actual facts rather than assumed ones. The tribunal has now agreed.
What the 2027 hearing will decide
Apple’s case, together with the parallel action brought by Privacy International and Liberty, will move to a full hearing during the first half of 2027, with a substantial portion now set to take place in public. Liberty expects a final hearing on the TCN regime the same year.
Apple and the Home Office have been contacted for comment.
The stakes reach beyond one company. For UK iCloud users, the case will determine whether the government can lawfully compel a technology firm to weaken the encryption that protects their data — and whether businesses caught between national security demands and user trust can fight back in open court.
Anyone affected by the outcome, from privacy campaigners to companies handling sensitive customer data, may want advice from specialists in data protection law or civil liberties organisations as the 2027 hearing approaches.
Hart framed the wider concern: “At a time of growing cyber threats, governments should be rising to the challenge to strengthen digital security protections rather than opening the door to hackers and hostile actors.”
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal, the body that delivered Thursday’s judgment, was established by the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, replacing three separate tribunals that had previously overseen the intelligence services. Though part of the Home Office, it operates independently of government and of the rest of the UK tribunal system, with its judicial independence enshrined in law by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005.
Unlike most UK courts, it mostly uses an inquisitorial system rather than an adversarial one, a reflection of the confidential evidence it handles — and the vast majority of its decisions are made on paper alone, with only a small percentage of cases reaching an oral hearing.
The technical details of the order remain secret. Whether they can lawfully stay that way is the question the tribunal will answer next year.
Keep reading
- People’s Daily: 2.358M Grassroots Graft Cases Handled, 1.63M Disciplined as Party Moves to Normalized Rectification
- Israel Railways Boosts Jerusalem Trains to Three Per Hour From Nov 29
- What Trump's Housing Order Means for a $360,000 Loan at 7.32% (daybreakwire.com)
- Apple to Stand Trial in Paris for Planned Obsolescence Over iPhone Repair Blocks (archyde.com)