Lawyer Accuses Government of ’Double Standards’ in Tom Phillips Inquiry
WELLINGTON, New Zealand – prominent lawyer Dennis Gates has publicly accused the Government of applying “double standards” in its handling of the inquiry into allegations of abuse at Gloriavale, specifically concerning the case of Tom Phillips. Gates, representing former Gloriavale members, claims the level of scrutiny and resources dedicated to Phillips’ case contrasts sharply with the approach taken regarding broader allegations of systemic abuse within the isolated community.
The criticism stems from the Government’s decision to launch a separate, independent inquiry focused solely on the circumstances surrounding Phillips’ departure from Gloriavale and subsequent attempts to reintegrate, while a wider investigation into historical allegations of abuse – including claims of child suffocation – continues through police and Oranga Tamariki.Gates argues this prioritisation suggests a disproportionate concern for Phillips, a high-profile figure who publicly shared his story, over the experiences of numerous other alleged victims. “It feels like there’s one rule for Tom and another for everyone else who suffered within Gloriavale,” Gates stated.
The inquiry into Phillips’ case, announced earlier this month, will be led by independent investigator David Jones QC. It will examine the actions of Oranga Tamariki and other government agencies in relation to Phillips’ welfare and reintegration efforts.
This development follows a New Zealand Herald investigation revealing police and Oranga Tamariki quietly launched a mass allegation investigation into the suffocation of babies and children at Gloriavale at the end of last year. More than 100 interviews were conducted, resulting in two formal police warnings.Police and OT also provided “suggested parenting techniques” to Gloriavale adults. This investigation was triggered by evidence presented at the Royal Commission.
Prior to the recent investigation, police and OT conducted a similar inquiry in 2017, offering parenting tips to Gloriavale leaders but concluding without formal warnings or enforcement action.
The current situation highlights ongoing concerns about the welfare of Gloriavale’s young people, with Minister for Children Karen Upston stating that their safety and ability to thrive is the “number one priority.” Upston has announced plans to visit the community “as early as possible” next year.
