Skip to main content
World Today News
  • Home
  • News
  • World
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Health
  • Technology
Menu
  • Home
  • News
  • World
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Health
  • Technology
Zurich University Hospital Pays Compensation in 14 Heart Surgery Scandal Cases

Zurich University Hospital Pays Compensation in 14 Heart Surgery Scandal Cases

November 20, 2026 Health Desk Health

The University Hospital of Zurich has paid compensation in 14 cases tied to its heart surgery scandal, with the hospital confirming the payments in a statement Swissinfo reported on Wednesday, November 19.

Key Clinical Takeaways:

  • Zurich’s University Hospital (USZ) has settled 14 of 20 compensation claims from patients and relatives affected by excess cardiac surgery deaths, for a total in the low six figures.
  • A report published in May found 68 to 74 more deaths than statistically expected across roughly 4,500 heart operations at the hospital.
  • The Zurich public prosecutor’s office is investigating three cases on suspicion of negligent homicide, negligent infliction of grievous bodily harm and document forgery, alongside 11 reports of inappropriate medical device use.

The payments are the hospital’s first concrete financial response to a scandal centered on Francesco Maisano, the former head of its cardiac surgery clinic. The hospital told SWI SWI swissinfo.ch it has reached out-of-court settlements with every claimant so far, and no legal proceedings have been initiated in any of the 14 resolved cases. Several claims remain pending.

The excess deaths behind the claims

The compensation stems from findings published in May that, out of approximately 4,500 heart surgeries performed at the USZ, between 68 and 74 more patients died than would have been statistically expected at a comparable hospital. Those patients, the report concluded, might still be alive had they been operated on elsewhere.

The case has since widened into a criminal investigation. According to SWI SWI swissinfo.ch, the Zurich public prosecutor’s office is examining three cases on suspicion of manslaughter, causing grievous bodily harm through negligence, and forgery of documents. It has also received 11 reports concerning the inappropriate use of medical devices.

The Cardioband conflict of interest

At the center of the device allegations is the Cardioband, an implant designed to repair heart valves that Maisano helped to develop. Prosecutors allege he used the product even when it was often not the right clinical choice, and that he personally profited financially from its use, Swissinfo reported.

Zurich University Hospital Pays Compensation in 14 Heart Surgery Scandal Cases
Photo: ctol.digital

CTOL Digital Solutions, which has followed the case, reports that Maisano failed to disclose financial interests in companies involved in the device’s development, and that investigations found omissions of surgical complications — including wire fractures during cardiac procedures — from scientific publications.

CTOL also reports that Germany’s Federal Institute for Drugs and Medical Devices (BfArM) issued four safety warnings about the Cardioband, and that in one case screws from the device came loose and were found floating in a patient’s heart chamber.

Two mortality counts, one hospital

The outlets differ sharply on the human toll. Swissinfo and bluewin.ch, both citing the May report, put the excess deaths at 68 to 74. CTOL Digital Solutions states that up to 150 patient deaths could have been prevented had proper procedures been followed, a figure it attributes to an inquiry into Maisano’s surgical practices. The table below sets the two accounts side by side.

Source Operations reviewed Excess deaths reported
Swissinfo / bluewin.ch (May report) ~4,500 68–74
CTOL Digital Solutions not stated up to 150

The gap matters for how the case is ultimately judged: the lower figure reflects a statistical comparison against expected mortality across the hospital’s full surgical volume, while the higher figure, as CTOL frames it, counts deaths the inquiry linked to departures from proper procedure. Neither figure has been tested in court.

Warnings that came years earlier

The compensation payments also land against a backdrop of institutional criticism. CTOL Digital Solutions reports that cardiologist André Plass filed complaints about Maisano’s practices as early as 2019, that the hospital initially supported Maisano and dismissed whistleblowers including Plass, and that the institution has been criticized for a slow response and attempts to downplay the severity of the issue.

The hospital’s leadership has since publicly thanked the fired whistleblower, as Swissinfo reported in earlier coverage of the case.

Zurich University Hospital Pays Compensation in 14 Heart Surgery Scandal Cases
Photo: bluewin.ch

CTOL further reports that the hospital reached confidential settlements with some victims’ families before the scandal became public, with sums reportedly in the five-figure range. The current round of payments, disclosed in a written statement obtained by Keystone-SDA and first reported by Swiss public radio SRF, is in the low six figures overall — suggesting an average per-case payout that remains modest relative to the scale of the alleged harm.

CTOL also reports that legal proceedings against Maisano were eventually closed at one stage, leaving questions unanswered — a point that sits uneasily beside the criminal investigation now open at the Zurich prosecutor’s office. The hospital has filed its own criminal complaints in connection with the scandal, according to earlier Swissinfo reporting.

For the 14 families, the settlements close a financial chapter without any admission tested before a court. For the hospital, these represent a move from the confidential, case-by-case approach CTOL describes toward disclosed, out-of-court resolution of the claims. Six claims remain unresolved, and the prosecutor’s investigation into negligent homicide, bodily harm and forgery continues.

The case has become a reference point in Europe for how financial conflicts of interest in surgical innovation can distort clinical decision-making.

Patients weighing valve repair or replacement options — particularly device-based procedures like the Cardioband, which carries regulatory safety warnings in Germany — may reasonably want a second opinion from an independent cardiac surgery specialist, and families pursuing claims over surgical harm typically work with medical malpractice counsel familiar with hospital settlement practices.

For hospitals and device manufacturers, the case shows why disclosure of developer financial interests and independent review of surgeon-specific outcomes are treated as standard safeguards in cardiac programs. Compliance officers at device makers active in the EU are watching the 11 device-misuse reports, since they test how regulators police the boundary between clinical innovation and self-dealing.

The hospital has given no timeline for resolving the outstanding claims. The Zurich public prosecutor’s office has not said when it expects to conclude its investigation of the three criminal cases.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and scientific communication purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare provider regarding any medical condition, diagnosis, or treatment plan.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X

Worth a look

  • Hospital San José de Casablanca Prioritizes Early Dental Care for Children and Adolescents
  • Study: Furapyrrodole Promotes Nerve Repair, Mobility Recovery in MS Mouse Model
  • Jessie J Returns to Instagram After Breast Reconstruction Surgery (newsdirectory3.com)

Related

article, health, latest news, Society

Search:

World Today News

World Today News is your trusted source for global journalism — breaking headlines, in-depth analysis, and reporting from around the world.

Quick Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Accessibility statement
  • California Privacy Notice (CCPA/CPRA)
  • Contact
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA Policy
  • Do not sell my info
  • EDITORIAL TEAM
  • Terms & Conditions

Browse by Location

  • GB
  • NZ
  • US

Connect With Us

© 2026 World Today News. All rights reserved. Your trusted global news source directory.
For contact, advertising, copyright, issues email: [email protected]

Privacy Policy Terms of Service