Mom of 5 Now Regrets Not Enjoying Child-Free Years During IVF Struggle
In a first-person column for Business Insider, writer Gillian Harvey argues she should have enjoyed her childfree years more, looking back on a fertility struggle that began three years before her first child was born via IVF in 2009.
Harvey, now a mother of five, writes that she spent her 30s consumed by the attempt to conceive, and that the years before parenthood now look wasted in hindsight. Business Insider is inviting readers to send their own parenting regrets to contributor Jennifer Beck Goldblatt at [email protected].
The piece rests on a timeline the author lays out herself: a first in-vitro fertilization round in 2007 that failed, a successful second attempt that made her a mother in December 2009, twin boys 18 months after that, and two more children since, bringing the total to five.
A “glass half empty” decade
Harvey writes that she once assumed pregnancy would come quickly, because her generation was taught it was “an almost inevitable result of having unprotected sex,” as she puts it in the Business Insider column. It did not. She reports she did not conceive in the first month, the second, “or even the fourteenth.”
While she waited, she writes, friends and family members announced pregnancies of their own. At the time it felt like a conspiracy; she now reads it as ordinary luck among women in their 30s. She dreaded Facebook announcements and felt “sick with envy” at scan photos posted online.

Her first IVF round came in 2007. When it failed a week before her first nephew was born, she writes that she “felt so broken” and vowed never to try again.
Harvey did try again, but she describes the two years between the failed cycle and the successful one as a blur in which babies occupied her every thought. She distanced herself from friends with children and avoided family Christmases, according to her account.
She records one exchange that still stings. When friends with kids complained about sleepless nights or called her “lucky” to be childfree, she writes, “it felt like a slap in the face.”
She is candid that she did not handle it well. “I wish I could say I found joy in others’ success, pitched in, helped out,” she writes, but the feeling of being infertile was so all-consuming that she retreated into herself instead.
December 2009, then twins
The turning point came in 2009, when she and her husband decided to try again, and that December she gave birth to a daughter. Twin brothers followed 18 months later, and she describes the result as “a whirlwind of nappies and short-lived naps.”

Life, she writes, was wonderful in a new way but would never be the same. Two more children later, she now fantasizes less about a full house and more about going to bed at a reasonable hour, having someone else cook, and finding time for what she calls “that thing they call self-care.”
The regret the column argues for
The core of Harvey’s argument is about allocation of time, not family size. She states plainly that she would not change her situation, and that she knows she is lucky. What she regrets is how hard she was on herself during the waiting years — time spent Googling fertility statistics, worrying about a lonely old age, and feeling haunted by images of women cradling baby bumps.
She concedes hindsight is easy: at the time, she did not know how the story would end. Even so, she writes, “there are years of my life that, looking back, seem wasted,” years she says she might have spent at the theatre, on an exotic holiday, or in hour-long bubble baths.
Harvey, who signed with Boldwood Books in 2022, is a freelance journalist and the author of two women’s fiction novels previously published by Orion. She drew on a long apprenticeship before that breakthrough: she started her first novel at 19, finished a ghost story called “Fordlan Farm” at 24 while working as a schoolteacher, and collected rejections sent by post before the industry moved online.
She moved to France in 2009 — the same year her first child was born — and later built her journalism career through a long-distance writing course, landing her first commission with the English-language newspaper Connexion. Her first title for Boldwood, “A Year at the French Farmhouse,” was published in September 2022, and her books have since sold over 600,000 copies.
Harvey closes with advice to her younger self, framed as a stored reserve rather than a lesson in patience. “Like a squirrel storing nuts for the winter,” she writes, “she should stack up her late nights and lie-ins while she can.”