Experts: China Sidelines Putin at Summit With Russian and U.S. Leaders
Russia’s president was seated next to the Chinese leader’s wife at a state dinner in Shenzhen while the U.S. president met Xi Jinping for two hours, a protocol arrangement that 24 Канал reported signaled Beijing’s view of Moscow as a junior partner.
The three-way summit in China produced no joint communique on Ukraine, no nuclear agreements, and no new security architecture, political scientist Oleg Saakyan told 24 Канал. “There is no common interest, no common agenda — neither nuclear, nor security, nor broader geopolitical, nor regarding the Russian-Ukrainian war,” Saakyan said.
He described the gathering as a photo session: Putin inflating his domestic image, Xi demonstrating that both Washington and Moscow come to Beijing, and Trump interrupting his campaign narrative.
Protocol hierarchy places Putin on the periphery
Xi greeted Trump personally at the venue, matching the protocol reserved for the leader of the other global superpower, 24 Канал reported. Putin was received by the fifth-ranking official in the Chinese hierarchy.
During the group photograph, Xi conspicuously did not shake Putin’s outstretched hand; the Chinese first lady, Peng Liyuan, was positioned between the two men. At the banquet, Putin was seated next to Peng Liyuan, physically separating him from Trump and Xi, according to Espreso.tv, citing foreign policy expert Liudmyla Pokrovska.
“China deliberately tried to separate Putin from Trump so they would not stand next to each other and could not even communicate,” Pokrovska told Espreso.tv. She said that even Putin’s aide, Yuri Ushakov, acknowledged the presidents did not speak during the dinner.
The Kremlin had hoped for a bilateral meeting on the sidelines, but the Chinese hosts controlled the schedule to minimize direct contact between the Russian and American leaders.
Trump-Putin talks last 40 minutes with translation
A bilateral meeting between Trump and Putin did eventually occur, but lasted only 40 minutes, compared to the two hours allotted for Trump and Xi, Pokrovska told Espreso.tv. Because Putin does not speak English, up to half of that window was consumed by interpretation.
“With these 40 minutes, if there was any dialogue at all, a maximum of 20 minutes fell to direct communication, according to Espreso. What could be agreed in such time?” Pokrovska said. She assessed the exchange as limited to general phrases, mutual assurances of respect, and diplomatic pleasantries.
China benefits from prolonged Ukraine war
China has no incentive to push for an end to the war in Ukraine, Saakyan told 24 Канал. A low-intensity, attritional conflict weakens Russia, consumes U.S. attention and resources, and fractures transatlantic unity — all outcomes that expand Beijing’s strategic space.
“China is quite satisfied that Russia is weakening. The U.S. is in a state of dependence because the topic of the war in Ukraine forces them to react, shrink, and destabilize internally,” Saakyan said. He added that Beijing avoids direct mediation to prevent being “bogged down” as it perceives Russia in Ukraine and the U.S. in the Middle East.
Xi finds the absence of European agency in peace talks unacceptable, just as he rejects violations of territorial integrity, Saakyan said. China does not recognize any Russian territorial gains because it needs Europe and the U.S. divided — a dynamic Trump advances by undermining alliance cohesion.
Comparisons to the 1945 Yalta Conference are “a picture for the Russian media space,” Saakyan said, noting China views Yalta as a historic trauma where Western powers partitioned Chinese territory.
Live: Russian President Vladimir Putin arrives in Shenzhen, China, for the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting, which will be held on November 18 and 19. #APECChinaYear #APECChina2026 https://t.co/l0t8Oy1DuG
Russia seeks bilateral pacts to fracture NATO
Moscow’s recent proposals for non-aggression pacts with individual European states and a European security system including Russia aim to create alternative security contours inside the alliance, Saakyan told 24 Канал.
“If you have weak links, countries where right-wing radicals can come to power and sign such acts, this will mean that NATO can be crossed out, because different security contours regarding the key threat in Europe will appear inside the Alliance,” he said. Russia uses Trump’s rhetoric as a lever while he retains influence, attempting to deepen splits within the Western coalition.
Trump’s influence limited by Congress and allies
Saakyan argued Trump lacks the instruments to force a settlement on Russian terms. “He has no tools to compel Ukraine. No hard tools to compel Europe. Even tools within the United States to do everything he wants — he no longer has them,” Saakyan said, citing Congressional pushback on Starlink, Starshield, and Patriot system decisions, according to 24 Канал.
Republican lawmakers have signaled they will not support moves that undermine Ukraine’s position. Any agreement requiring sequential implementation steps is unenforceable, Saakyan said, because Trump faces a “lame duck” timeline for sustained foreign policy action.
China waits for structural collapse before acting
Beijing will not make sharp moves absent extraordinary circumstances — a “black swan” or “white swan” event — Saakyan told 24 Канал. “China is waiting for everyone else to bury themselves deeper, and then, by virtue of that, be higher and able to take advantage of the situation,” he said.
If China eventually plays the Ukraine card, it will likely do so with Europe, not Washington, to secure European markets and prevent solidarity with the U.S. over Taiwan. Saakyan said he does not expect Beijing to use blunt military force for reunification, noting November and December as critical months for observing the next phase of Chinese strategy.
Peng Liyuan, born 20 November 1962, rose to national fame in the early 1980s as a folk singer after performing “On the Fields of Hope” on the CMG New Year’s Gala.
She earned the Plum Blossom Award, China’s highest theatre honour, for her 1985 portrayal of Xi’er in “The White-Haired Girl,” and in 1990 became the country’s first master’s graduate in folk vocal music from the China Conservatory of Music. She served as president of the People’s Liberation Army Academy of Art from 2012 to 2017 before assuming the role of first lady.
“The most expensive photo set in the history of Russia. And I think that is the key conclusion and the key intrigue: what Putin paid for it.”
Oleg Saakyan, political scientist, to 24 Канал
Kerch Bridge strikes before the summit added military-logistical and psychological pressure on the Kremlin, Saakyan noted. The irony was stark: Putin observed Chinese engineering marvels in Shenzhen, including advanced bridge construction, while his own strategic bridge in Crimea degraded.
More on Putin
🇨🇳🇷🇺🇺🇸On November 19, President Xi Jinping will hold the #China-#Russia-#US Summit with President Vladimir Putin and President Donald J. Trump in #Shenzhen. Chinese FM Spokesperson: The China-Russia-U. S. Shenzhen Summit will be the first ever face-to-face meeting between the… pic.twitter.com/3UGMCS26WX