São Paulo Court Upholds Acquittal Despite “Demon” Remark
The Court of São Paulo decided on June 24 that a lawyer using the word “demon” during a jury trial is not enough to annul the verdict.
Presidente Prudente Court Proceedings
Prosecutor João Paulo Giovanini Gonçalves appealed an acquittal by arguing that attorney Mário André Badures Gomes Martins used the expression after the reply to sway jurors and hurt the Public Prosecutor’s Office, Jurinews reported in its full decision here.
The prosecutor claimed the defense lawyer called the ministerial replica “absurd” and tried to exploit the timing of the trial alongside a Brazil match in the Copa do Mundo.
Sessions at Fórum de Presidente Prudente ran from the prosecutor’s reply at 6:34 p.m. to 7:34 p.m., followed by the defense triple from 7:43 p.m. to 8:43 p.m., when the contested expression was recorded. The jury concluded at 9:10 p.m., after Brazil secured a 3–0 victory over Scotland, which led to a majority vote acquitting the defendant on a first-degree attempted murder charge.
Appellate Ruling and Legal Standard
Appellate judge rapporteur Amable Lopez Soto rejected the preliminary nullity request, with appellate judges Sérgio Mazina Martins and Nogueira Nascimento joining the panel. The magistrate concluded that the remark was merely “retorical vehemence” that did not damage the prosecution or compromise the impartiality of the council of judgment.
“Use of demon term in jury does not annul TJ-SP decision,” Jurinews reported, detailing how the court cited Articles 563 and 566 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The ruling states that invalidating a jury requires proof of effective injury rather than mere guesswork about language or external events.
The Court of São Paulo functions as the judicial branch of the state government, maintaining jurisdiction across its 56 judiciary districts.
As the head of the judiciary, the court serves as the final appellate authority for sentences issued within these districts, with its specific assignments defined by Article 74 of the São Paulo State Constitution. This structure enables the court to oversee a massive volume of legal matters, which included over 5 million new cases filed during 2024.
Operating with a body of 360 desembargadores and a total of 729 judges, the court manages a wide array of responsibilities, ranging from original jurisdiction in criminal offenses involving high-ranking state officials to resolving conflicts of attribution between administrative and judiciary authorities.
Judge Henrique Ramos Sorgi Macedo had previously turned down a defense motion to question jurors about any distractions regarding the match, which was set for 19 hours, according to the session minutes. On the merits of the case, the panel maintained the verdict under the constitutional sovereignty of popular jury decisions, noting that two plausible readings of the evidence prevent the court from overriding the outcome.