São Paulo Appeals Court Rules Athlete Brokering Is Export, Exempt From ISS
The São Paulo State Court of Appeals (TJSP) ruled that the brokering of Brazilian athletes to international soccer clubs is exempt from the Services Tax (ISS), setting a major precedent for global talent transactions.
This judicial decision, handed down by the 18th Public Law Chamber of the TJSP, determines that the services provided by Elenko Sports are transactions of an export nature because the ultimate benefit—the player’s performance—is consumed abroad. The ruling directly challenged the São Paulo city government, which had been fining the agency under the argument that the service occurred within Brazilian territory.
The Core Ruling on Service Taxation
The agency Elenko Sports, represented by tax partners Raphael Caropreso and Filipe Richter of Veirano Advogados, sued the city of São Paulo after being subjected to multiple fines. The city claimed the fees earned by the agency were subject to the ISS, which taxes services rendered within municipal borders. The company challenged these assessments, arguing the nature of the transaction transcended local jurisdiction.
The TJSP’s 18th Public Law Chamber ultimately rejected the city’s claims, ruling that the city government’s initial appeals were without merit. The court applied the “enjoyment theory” to the case. This theory posits that taxation must be based on where the useful result of a service is actually enjoyed, not merely where the service is administered.
Judge Marcelo L. Theodósio, who wrote the rapporteur’s opinion for the chamber, said that the conclusion of an athlete’s employment contract necessitates actions taken overseas. These actions include medical examinations and the signing of the agreement, which “show unequivocally that the service is not completed in Brazilian territory.”
This logic establishes that the services brokered by Elenko Sports—the transfer of players to clubs in Italy, Portugal, France, South Korea, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and Japan—are effectively completed in the foreign market. Therefore, the service is consumed abroad, classifying the transaction as an export.
Broader Implications for the Global Soccer Market
The ruling is considered a “watershed” moment for the soccer market and related sectors, providing clarity where previous case law had been inconsistent. For years, the São Paulo tax authority consistently fined athlete brokers based on the premise that the service was performed physically within Brazil. This has created significant financial uncertainty for agencies operating internationally.
Richter of Veirano Advogados explained that the ambiguity stems from the wording of Complementary Law 116 of 2003, which governs the ISS. He noted, “Complementary Law 116 of 2003, which governs the ISS, adopted the destination principle of taxation, but its wording leaves room for a series of disputes.”
The city government’s initial position relied on the physical location of the agent, but the court shifted the focus to the client’s benefit. The fees collected by the agency are substantial because foreign clubs convert currency and pay the companies in dollars, but the court ruled that the benefits flow to the foreign entity and the player’s career path.
“In practice, this significantly narrows the scope of the appeals and strengthens the chances that the favorable decision we obtained at the TJSP will stand,” Raphael Caropreso, who represented the agency, said. He noted, “In practice, this significantly narrows the scope of the appeals and strengthens the chances that the favorable decision we obtained at the TJSP will stand.”
The list of clubs associated with the transfers handled by Elenko Sports illustrates the international scope of the services covered by the ruling.
These transfers included moves to Roma in Italy, Moreirense Futebol Clube in Portugal, GNK Dinamo in Croatia, Bordeaux in France, Daegu Football Club in South Korea, Al-Wehda Club in Saudi Arabia, Sporting Clube de Braga in Portugal, Gaziantep Futbol Kulubu in Turkey, and Gamba Osaka in Japan. This pattern of international movement is the central fact upon which the tax exemption rests.
Interplay with Brazil’s Tax Reform
This judicial victory arrives as Brazil moves toward sweeping tax reform. The current system of ISS is slated for replacement by the Goods and Services Tax (IBS). This shift is critical because the IBS will be governed by a similar “destination principle” framework, which aligns with the court’s current ruling.
Tax reform, established under Constitutional Amendment 132 of 2023, aims to replace both the ISS and the state-level ICMS with the new levy. This transition is a long-term development; the IBS is scheduled for a 0.1% rate next year and will be fully implemented starting in 2033. This future legislation is designed to treat consumption based on the place where it occurs.
Tax lawyer Ricardo Maito of TozziniFreire suggests that the new reform will likely settle the long-standing debate over service exports. He posits that once the IBS and CBS (Contribution on Goods and Services) regulations are fully enacted, the current disputes surrounding ISS will fade into historical context.
Maito said that Complementary Law 214, which regulates the reform, will list specific situations where consumption is presumed to happen outside Brazil, treating them as exports.
This shift promises a more predictable environment for international business. Under the new system, services provided on foreign real estate, for example, will be treated as exports and consequently exempt from the new IBS and CBS.
“This is fantastic, because it will allow a range of services, such as business brokering and consulting, to be covered by that presumption,” Maito said. The ability to define consumption by its destination provides a clear mechanism for services that operate across borders.
City Appeals Ruling to Higher Courts
Despite the favorable decision for Elenko Sports at the TJSP level, the legal battle is not over. The São Paulo city government maintains its position that collecting the ISS is lawful and consistent with existing legislation. Consequently, the city’s Attorney General’s Office has filed appeals with the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) and the Supreme Court to seek a review of the TJSP’s decision.
The city’s attempt to appeal the ruling at the TJSP failed, as the 18th Chamber unanimously rejected their initial efforts. However, the appeal to the STJ and the Supreme Court introduces a new layer of complexity and timing to the dispute. The outcome of these higher court challenges will determine the definitive legal status of athlete brokering fees across Brazil.
The debate centers on the interpretation of the “result” under the destination principle. While the city argues the service is performed in Brazil, the court and the agency argue the value is realized internationally. This tension highlights the need for clear legal direction for multinational agencies.
Ultimately, the trajectory of this case points toward a clearer definition of service consumption in the digital age. The final word, however, rests with the higher courts.