Fincher’s ‘Cliff Booth’ Spinoff Reviewed as B- Compromise Between Tarantino and Fincher
David Fincher’s “The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth,” Quentin Tarantino’s scripted spinoff of “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” earned a B- from IndieWire in a review ahead of the film’s Netflix release.
The verdict frames the movie as a compromised meeting of two very different sensibilities: a breezy showbiz throwback Tarantino originally planned to direct himself, handed instead to the director IndieWire calls “modern Hollywood’s most unsentimental technician.”
According to the review, that handoff forces the film into “a muted but fascinating tug-of-war between the past tense and the future perfect” — a tension the critic argues the streamer’s own scratchy “vintage” Netflix logo articulates “with a greater clarity of purpose than any other part of this perverse collaboration.”
David Fincher’s “The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth” is a wild, hilarious hangout movie. Brad Pitt slides back into his beloved Oscar-winning role and gives his best performance since “Once Upon a Time in… Hollywood.” Elizabeth Debicki brings an intoxicating sensuality,… pic.twitter.com/Z4Ec0AWiAm
The film catches up with Brad Pitt’s Cliff Booth, the stuntman who memorably stole “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood” and an Oscar along the way.
Reborn as the lead of a Fincher film, he is reintroduced working the projector at the New Beverly Cinema, while quietly working a far more lucrative side gig as a Hollywood fixer. IndieWire describes him as “still hot, cool, and at total peace with himself despite an increasingly violent reputation.”
Slashfilm’s review, while warmer overall, strikes a similar note of ambivalence about the character’s promotion to leading man. The site praised Pitt’s original performance as “a funny, scene-stealing performance that landed him an Oscar,” but questioned the sequel’s central choice.
“I think the case can be made that Cliff Booth is a very charming psychopath,” the review said, adding that without Leonardo DiCaprio’s Rick Dalton by his side, the film “ends up frequently feeling cold and cruel.”

Slashfilm also reported that Tarantino — who has long said he will direct only 10 films and then retire — came close to making “The Movie Critic” only to drop the idea entirely, and is now working on his first stage play, “The Popinjay Cavalier.”
Because he doesn’t want to spend his tenth and final film just yet, he handed the “Hollywood” follow-up to Fincher, whose recent Netflix exclusivity the site notes is now over.
Set over a few days in the summer of 1977, when “Star Wars” is “the biggest force on Earth,” the film builds toward the October premiere of “Looking for Mr. Goodbar” in its parallel-universe Hollywood.
IndieWire notes the world around Cliff is uglier than it was eight years earlier, with Tarantino’s vibrant celluloid memory palace faded into “the computational muddiness that Fincher has come to mistake for the truth” — though drab cinematography and bad disco “don’t mean shit” to a man who lied about his age to join the Philippine resistance as a teenager during World War II.
PITT. TARANTINO. FINCHER. THE FURTHER MIS-ADVENTURES OF CLIFF BOOTH. ONLY IN IMAX NOVEMBER 25. GET TICKETS NOW. pic.twitter.com/x2bx6ASpDh
Peter Weller plays Cliff’s TV-obsessed father Gus Booth, with whom Cliff shares a small apartment in Marina del Rey, and “Anora” favorite Karren Karagulian features in the movie’s self-contained opening scene, which IndieWire warns proves that anyone would do well not to “underestimate Cliff Booth at your own peril.”
For all the friction between its two auteurs, the film is, per IndieWire, “pleasant enough for a movie so dark, and strangely relaxed for a movie so deeply self-conflicted” — ultimately about “someone changing with the times without letting the times change them in return.”
Fincher, born in Denver in 1962, made his feature debut with “Alien 3” in 1992 and broke through with “Seven” three years later. Before that, he co-founded Propaganda Films in 1986 and directed music videos for Madonna, winning the MTV Video Music Award for Best Direction for both “Express Yourself” and “Vogue.”
He went on to earn Academy Award nominations for Best Director for “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button,” “The Social Network” and “Mank,” and won a Primetime Emmy for directing the pilot of Netflix’s “House of Cards,” the series that began his run at the streamer.

IndieWire’s full review runs alongside Slashfilm’s, with additional coverage at AmeriLedger.