THR Critics Rank the 25 Best New York Movies of All Time
New York movie canon got a rewrite this week: The Hollywood Reporter published a ranked list of the 25 best New York movies of all time on Wednesday, timed to three new NYC-set films now in theaters — Club Kid, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York and James Gray’s crime drama Paper Tiger.
The ranking arrives, as khanlist.com notes in its syndication of the piece, from THR film critics who set out to settle a subgenre “as rich and varied as the city itself.” Two of the four were born and raised in New York — one in Manhattan, one in Queens. One has lived in Chelsea for 25 years. One is a Californian with deep family roots in Brooklyn.
The stakes of the exercise go beyond listicle season. The critics started from a shortlist of roughly 100 titles, then debated their way down to 25. Along the way they made editorial calls that will ruffle fan bases: no documentaries, one film per filmmaker, and — most contentious — no When Harry Met Sally, Ghostbusters, Working Girl or The Devil Wears Prada.
Why the beloved hits got cut
The exclusions were deliberate, The Hollywood Reporter explained: the mainstream favorites were left off “not because we don’t have affection for them,” but because other titles used the city more distinctively — in many cases making New York “really a character in and of itself.”
That logic shapes the list’s texture. Some picks celebrate the city’s sheer energy. Others, the critics write, are marked by “solitude and despair, chaos and murder, because New York is a town that has broken many a soul.”

The anthem framing came from Brooklyn: the critics reached for Jay-Z’s “Empire State of Mind” — “Eight million stories out there in the naked city; it’s a pity half of y’all won’t make it” — a line that itself nods to Jules Dassin’s 1948 noir The Naked City.
New York was Hollywood first
The historical spine of the argument, per The Hollywood Reporter: American cinema began in New York — or, strictly speaking, across the Hudson at Thomas Edison’s New Jersey lab, where the Kinetoscope was invented.
Edwin S. Porter’s The Great Train Robbery (1903) was shot partly at Edison’s Manhattan studios, and D.W. Griffith’s earliest work was made there before Biograph built a larger stage in the Bronx. Mack Sennett, who launched Charlie Chaplin’s career, started at Biograph too.
The studios decamped west, though the piece flags a reversal: Netflix is now headed back east with a ginormous new facility in Jersey. The boroughs never stopped producing auteurs — Martin Scorsese, Francis Ford Coppola, Spike Lee, Woody Allen, Sidney Lumet and John Cassavetes were all born or grew up in New York, and the list limits each to a single film to spread the wealth.
From 1974 subway heists to 2023 Harlem
The published portion of the ranking leans into range. A Thousand and One (2023), A.V. Rockwell’s Sundance winner, gives Teyana Taylor a powerhouse showcase as a single mother fresh from a stint at Rikers, set against the background of rapidly gentrifying 1990s New York — Brooklyn and Harlem in particular.
James Gray lands with his latest crime drama, Paper Tiger. Peter Sollett’s Raising Victor Vargas (2002) documents the Lower East Side’s Dominican community.
The list also reserves space for a film defined by its off-screen troubles. Kenneth Lonergan’s Margaret, shot in 2005 but mired in legal and editing-room disputes for years, reached theaters in 2011 — by which time, The Hollywood Reporter writes, many New Yorkers had tried to put Sept. 11 behind them.
The critics position it as the film that best channeled that period’s deep-seated malaise, alongside Spike Lee’s The 25th Hour which captured the rage and chaos of post-9/11 New York.
Ten that just missed
The honorable-mentions shelf is its own argument starter: The Naked City, All That Jazz, Escape From New York, Girlfriends, It Should Happen to You, Klute, Marty Supreme, Midnight Cowboy, Saturday Night Fever and Tiny Furniture. The critics concede these are films that could have made the list if it had been finalized another day.
For the film business, the timing is the point. A canon-ranking landing while three New York features play theaters — plus the fabulous doc Once Upon a Time in Harlem — is awards-season positioning of the plainest kind, and the kind of moment where publicists, talent agencies and location-savvy production services earn their keep on a city that remains cinema’s most bankable backdrop.
GlobeVerge and khanlist.com both carried the piece as syndicated THR material; the ranking, the methodology and the cuts are the magazine’s own. The full 25-title list, top to bottom, runs at The Hollywood Reporter — and the debate over what didn’t make it has only just started.
The ranking is the latest entry in a long publishing history: The Hollywood Reporter was founded in 1930 as Hollywood’s first daily entertainment trade newspaper, its first edition appearing on September 3, 1930 with a front-page column that became influential among studio bosses.
In 2010 the title switched from a daily paper to a weekly large-format print magazine with a revamped website, and it now publishes international editions in several countries while also sponsoring and hosting major industry events. Since 2020, its day-to-day operations have been handled by Penske Media Corporation through a joint venture with Eldridge Industries.
Disclaimer: The views and cultural analyses presented in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Information regarding legal disputes or financial data is based on available public records.