Cornell Psychologist Vanessa Bohns: Share Holiday Successes and Hardships
Social psychologist Vanessa Bohns says research backs being more forthcoming than most people assume during holiday gatherings, CNBC reported.
Bohns, the Braunstein Family Professor and Chair of Organizational Behavior at Cornell University’s ILR School, argues that sharing good news strengthens bonds through “basking in reflected glory,” while disclosing hardships often elicits more support and less judgment than anticipated. Her guidance draws on studies showing people who reveal insecurities are liked more than they expect, and that asking sensitive follow-up questions deepens connection without the awkwardness people predict.
“When we’re deciding whether to open up about our insecurities, we tend to focus on the thing we’re embarrassed about,” Bohns told CNBC. “But the person we choose to share with also learns that we are honest and trust them enough to share — qualities people really like.”
The calculus of good news
Hiding achievements to avoid envy can backfire, Bohns said. Relatives often want to celebrate a cousin’s promotion or a niece’s acceptance letter, and withholding the news can leave them feeling excluded later. She recommends sharing successes with care rather than downplaying them, which can read as disingenuous.
Envy, she noted, frequently carries an admiring component that can motivate others rather than breed resentment. The risk of a mixed reaction is not a reason to stay silent.
Hardships and the “magic ratio”
Research on couples by psychologist John Gottman identified a ratio of roughly five positive interactions for every negative one. Bohns suggests borrowing that framework for holiday meals: after opening up about a layoff or a breakup, allow the conversation several lighter turns before introducing another heavy topic.
“Does that mean you should dominate Thanksgiving dinner with your sad stories? Of course not,” Bohns told CNBC. “No one wants to be a Debbie Downer at the dinner table.”
Asking the personal question
People who ask more follow-up questions are better liked, studies show. Bohns advises checking the motive before probing: a genuine desire to understand a cousin’s rough year builds intimacy; curiosity about their salary does not.
Comments on appearance — weight changes, aging — are better left unsaid. Ask about the person, not the observation.
Bohns is the author of “Should I Say Something? The Science of What to Share—and What to Keep to Yourself.” She holds a Ph.D. in psychology from Columbia University and a bachelor’s degree from Brown University.
Bohns has appeared on NPR’s Life Kit, Adam Grant’s Work Life podcast, and the “Hidden Brain” podcast to discuss honesty, saying no, and social influence. She has also written for the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times on workplace consent and hard truths, and her research on compliance and asking for help has been published in Harvard Business Review.
Disclaimer: The views and cultural analyses presented in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Information regarding legal disputes or financial data is based on available public records.