Bishop Crociata Calls EU States’ Rwanda Return Hubs ‘Deportation
European Union member states, including Austria, Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark, and Greece, are advancing plans to establish return hubs in Rwanda for migrants denied residency.
Criticism of the Rwanda deportation plan
Monsignor Mariano Crociata, president of the Commission of the Bishops’ Conferences of the European Union (COMECE), described the initiative as having the “flavor of a deportation.” In an interview with Vatican News, he argued that the strategy effectively offloads the responsibility of migration management to a third country rather than addressing the underlying human needs of asylum seekers.
“The decision to outsource the placement of migrants is striking because it has the flavor of a deportation: it condemns these people to living conditions that are likely no better than those from which they fled, said Mariano Crociata, president of COMECE, to Vatican News.”
Crociata contended that the European Commission’s support for this approach reflects a broader trend of restricting asylum access. He said that the policy attempts to bypass the complexities of migration by treating the individuals involved as a “scapegoat” for deeper economic and social anxieties within European societies.
European Parliament approves repatriation regulation
On November 20, the European Parliament approved a new repatriation regulation with 418 votes in favor, 218 against, and 30 abstentions, as reported by Vatican News. This legislative move aligns with the broader push by several member states to formalize return mechanisms.

The proposed return hubs are slated for operation by July 2027, according to Internazionale. While proponents, including Christian Stocker, have framed the collaboration as a “historic paradigm shift,” the practical implementation remains uncertain. Internazionale said that the financial details of the Rwanda agreement remain undisclosed, and it is unclear how migrants will be integrated or eventually processed.
| Event | Key Figure or Detail |
|---|---|
| EU Parliament Repatriation Vote | 418 in favor, 218 against |
| Previous UK-Rwanda Project Cost | ~850 million euro |
| Italian Repatriations in 2025 | 4,784 total |
Similar projects have previously faced significant legal obstacles. In 2023, the UK’s Supreme Court blocked a proposed agreement with Rwanda, citing insufficient safeguards for fundamental human rights, as detailed by Avvenire. Italy’s attempt to establish processing centers in Albania has faced repeated challenges from the Italian judiciary, according to Internazionale.

Migrant boat capsizes off Lampedusa coast
The debate over migration policy comes as tragedies at sea continue. On November 19, a boat departing from Tunisia capsized off the coast of Lampedusa, resulting in the disappearance of a six-year-old girl, Vatican News reported. Such incidents have intensified calls from religious organizations for a shift toward solidarity.
Crociata emphasized that migration is a complex phenomenon that provides necessary labor for European economies facing low birth rates. He argued that instead of constructing artificial threats, policymakers should focus on improving economic conditions in countries of origin.
Mariano Crociata, who was born in 1953 in Castelvetrano, Sicily, began his ecclesiastical career after being ordained as a priest in 1979. Before his current leadership role, he served as the Secretary-General of the Italian Episcopal Conference between 2008 and 2013, becoming the first person to hold that position while hailing from a southern Italian diocese.
His academic background includes a doctorate in theology from the Pontifical Gregorian University of Rome. Prior to his episcopal appointments, he directed the theology of religions department at Palermo’s Theological School, where he organized numerous conferences focusing on Islam.
The project’s ability to influence migration flows, given that previous estimates suggest millions of people are involved in migration routes between the EU and the UK, remains a subject of debate among policy analysts.