$811M Fine Fails to Halt Predatory Migrant Bail Scheme
A federal judge fined Libre by Nexus and its founders $811 million in 2024 for a predatory bail scheme targeting detained migrants, but public records and interviews show connected operations continued collecting fees and fitting ankle monitors after the order.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau sued the company, its parent firm, and principals Richard Ajin, William Donovan, and Robert Moore, alleging they concealed non‑refundable monthly charges and misrepresented them as bond payments. U.S. District Judge Dolly Gee found the defendants liable and barred them from collecting past debts, according to court filings reviewed by BBC News.
Ankle monitors kept appearing after the judgment
Mark Supetran, a former call‑center employee based in the Philippines, told BBC News he worked for the company for a few months in 2022 and the electronic bracelets were standard issue. “Part of the script was to say something like: ‘The client will be wearing an ankle monitor.’ So that got me thinking, like, why? It doesn’t make sense, we’re not the government,” Supetran said.
Another former employee, who spoke to BBC News on condition of anonymity, said supervisors instructed staff to promise callers their bail deposits would be returned once immigration cases ended. “But that that was never the case. I mean, you had people calling me in almost every day like ‘Hey, am I gonna get my money back? Am I gonna get my money back?'” the former employee told the network.

Ajin told BBC News the contract stated plainly that monthly fees were programme fees, not bond payments, and therefore non‑refundable.
Days after the 2024 injunction, Donovan sold customer lists, records, and other assets to a buyer who also assumed the company’s debt — for $3.50, according to transfer documents seen by BBC News. Ajin said he cut ties with everyone involved after the sale.
Moore is now in prison after a conviction for filing fraudulent Nexus tax returns. He and Donovan are awaiting sentencing on separate insurance‑fraud and conspiracy charges. Donovan has also been charged with sexually abusing a boy under 12; he has not entered a plea in that case, court records show.
New entity, same playbook
Mildred Juárez, detained at a Texas immigration center, wired $2,600 to LIS on her lawyer’s recommendation, she told BBC News. Daily calls to the facility brought the same answer: her bond had not been paid.
An LIS email reviewed by the network claimed a cash bond had been sent to ICE, but Juárez was ultimately released by a different bail agent after her friends raised more money. LIS never refunded her deposit.
An LIS spokesperson told BBC News that Juárez “misunderstands” their role — they connect detainees to licensed bondsmen rather than posting bond themselves — and said a refund would be issued once her friend verified details. The White House and the Department of Homeland Security did not respond to BBC requests for comment.
Detention surge fuels demand
Since President Donald Trump returned to office promising an immigration crackdown, Immigration and Customs Enforcement has made more than 1.2 million arrests and accelerated deportations, according to agency data cited by BBC News. The administration has sought to eliminate bail for migrants but has been blocked in court, leaving a growing detained population reliant on private bond companies.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, created by the 2010 Dodd–Frank Act after the 2008 financial crisis, was originally proposed in 2007 by then‑professor Elizabeth Warren. An independent bureau inside the Federal Reserve, it consolidates consumer‑protection duties once spread across seven federal agencies and has returned more than $21 billion to harmed consumers since opening.
“I was losing it inside there. I lost everything. When I was released I had nightmares I was back inside.”
Mildred Juárez, former detainee, to BBC News
The CFPB’s enforcement action remains the largest consumer‑protection judgment against an immigration‑services firm.