DOJ Delays ‘Sabungero’ Case Hearing Pending Evidence, Ang and Barretto Deny Allegations
MANILA – Proceedings in the Department of Justice (DOJ) examination into the disappearance of several “sabungeros” (cockfighting aficionados) have been stalled due to incomplete evidence, and both businessman Charlie “Atong” Ang and former Quezon City Representative sandra Errol Tulfo Barretto have refuted accusations leveled against them.
Attorney Dennis Villareal, representing Ang, stated that a subpoena served to them included only two of seven identified USB drives, with the remaining five represented only by photocopies lacking the actual data. “How can we respond properly if the evidence itself is missing?” Villareal questioned. He also cited delays stemming from complainants recently submitting sworn affidavits,including whistleblower julie Patidongan.
Barretto’s lawyer,Alma Mallonga,dismissed the accusations as “bare allegations” lacking substantiation,asserting,”Suspicions,rumors,and speculations are not evidence. There’s no evidence in this case.” she expressed confidence the complaints would be dismissed.
Villareal further denied allegations that ang attempted to settle related cases before the Manila Regional Trial Court, noting Ang is not an accused in those proceedings. He pointed out that Patidongan and her co-accused, not Ang, are the defendants in those cases, and suggested the accused have a motive to settle, particularly after Patidongan’s bail was reversed. “Why would Ang attempt to settle when he is not even charged? It is indeed the accused who stand to benefit from any compromise,” Villareal stated.
Villareal warned that reopening the case could undermine years of proceedings as the complaints were first filed in 2022, alleging attempts to implicate Ang are a tactic to deflect from the wrongdoing of those actually facing charges.
Prosecutor Charlie Guhit confirmed that only Barretto has submitted a counter-affidavit and that the DOJ has ordered the Philippine National Police (PNP) to submit the missing USB drives before the next hearing on September 29. The prosecution panel will not compel respondents to file counter-affidavits until the evidence is complete.
The disappearance of the “sabungeros” remains unresolved after more than three years, with families continuing to seek justice as the case remains in the preliminary investigation phase.
