Veteran Critic Finds Pauline Julien Film Impressionistic, Not Biopic
A new film about the late Quebec singer Pauline Julien has reached Montreal screens, and one critic who knew her personally is not convinced it does her justice.
“Pauline Julien: femme pays,” directed by Anaïs Barbeau-Lavalette, opened to a lukewarm reception from Le Journal de Montréal columnist who saw it at the Cinéma Beaubien.
Writing after the screening, the veteran journalist said he arrived “fébrile and curious,” expecting a biopic that would recall the best moments of an artist who had moved him with her own songs and with those of Vignault, Léo Ferré, Barbara and others. Instead, he came away cold.
Rather than a biopic, he described an impressionistic feature film, fairly repetitive, cut into fragments in a disorienting way and multiplying extreme close-ups, several of which he called questionable. He was also unmoved by the film’s staging of “Manic,” Georges Dor’s famous song, which Julien sings in the movie among motionless workers with whom she has, strangely, no connection, according to the review.
The critic nonetheless credited the film with faithfully revealing the exuberant, passionate Julien that audiences knew, her ambiguous relationships with her children and her extravagant love affair with Gérald Godin, less sovereignist than she was, he observed. He predicted the film will surely earn several acting awards for Suzanne Clément.
For viewers left hungry, the columnist recommended Pascale Ferland’s 2018 documentary “Pauline Julien, intime et politique,” available on the NFB’s website.
Julien died in Montreal in 1998, four years after Godin, her last partner. The critic wrote that he met her in 1957, when she returned to Quebec after several years in France, where she had mainly worked as an actress.
He later crossed paths with her in Paris after her success at the Olympia, sharing for years the same circle of artists exiled in France to escape the grasp of the clergy and Duplessis in Quebec.
As for Barbeau-Lavalette, the reviewer called her a woman of many talents, noting her films such as “La déesse des mouches à feu,” the documentary “Pas perdus” made with her partner Émile Proulx-Cloutier, and novels including “La femme qui fuit,” winner of the Governor General’s prize.
His verdict on the title itself: “Femme pays! Quelle grosse commande!” — what a heavy order to place on one woman’s shoulders.
Related reading