eden Gardens Pitch Under Fire as Uneven Bounce Dominates India-South Africa Test
Kolkata, November 15, 2025 – The first Test match between India and South Africa at Eden Gardens in Kolkata has been heavily impacted by a severely uneven pitch, drawing criticism from fans and raising questions about pitch preparation. the match is unfolding at a rapid pace, with batting proving exceptionally arduous due to unpredictable bounce.
The match began with South Africa winning the toss and choosing to bat, but they were quickly dismissed for 176. Dean Elgar and David Bedingham contributed considerably with scores of 55 and 56 respectively, while India’s prasidh Krishna and Mohammed Siraj each took three wickets. India responded with 189, securing a crucial 30-run first-innings lead. KL Rahul was the top scorer for the home side with 39 runs. South african bowlers Simon harmer (4 wickets) and Marco jansen (3 wickets) were notably effective.
In their second innings, South Africa struggled again, finding themselves at 66 for 5 in the final session of Day 2. Ravindra Jadeja claimed four wickets,exploiting the challenging conditions.
The pitch,described as a “rank turner,” exhibited pronounced uneven bounce from the opening day,particularly from one end. This has led to concerns about player safety and the quality of the contest between bat and ball.Fans have voiced their disappointment online, with many questioning the decision to prepare such a challenging surface. Some criticized the Indian team management, referencing the 0-3 loss to New Zealand last year where spin-friendly pitches backfired.
Social media reactions included comments labeling the pitch a “disgrace” and expressing concern that the Test match might conclude prematurely. One fan noted the irony of the situation, recalling hopes that lessons had been learned from the New Zealand series. Others questioned whether the pitch was a disservice to the large crowds attending the match at Eden Gardens.
The situation is particularly frustrating given statements made by Eden Gardens curator Sujan Mukherjee prior to the Test. Mukherjee had stated his intention to create a “good sporting wicket” offering ”something for everyone,” despite a request from the team management for a spinner-friendly pitch. He had assured that the pitch would offer both turn and bounce, suitable for both batters and bowlers.
Despite the difficult conditions, South Africa captain Temba Bavuma demonstrated resilience in the second innings, facing over 10 overs while wickets fell around him.
The match continues to unfold quickly, with the uneven bounce significantly influencing the outcome and sparking debate about the suitability of the Eden Gardens pitch for Test cricket.
