Umpire’s Timing call in World Series Game 7 Fuels Debate Over Ohtani Rule
ARLINGTON,TX – A precise timing call by the home plate umpire during the seventh inning of Game 7 of the World Series between the Dodgers and the Blue Jays has sparked controversy,centering on the request of MLB’s rules regarding pitcher timing and the unique two-way status of dodgers star Shohei Ohtani. The incident occurred as ohtani, having finished batting in the top of the inning, prepared to take the mound for the bottom half.
The debate stems from a rule clarification issued by MLB and relayed by Jon Morosi of MLB Network on November 2, 2025: “If the pitcher is on base, on deck or at bat when the inning ends, the timer begins when the pitcher leaves the dugout for the mound.” This rule, intended to streamline game pace, became a focal point due to the Dodgers’ roster advantage stemming from Ohtani’s ability to both pitch and hit. The Dodgers were permitted to carry an extra pitcher on their World Series roster due to Ohtani’s dual role, a decision that reportedly drew criticism from other teams.
The controversy surrounding Ohtani’s status extends beyond the pitching timer. As reported by USA Today’s Bob nightengale in September, teams expressed concern over the potential for strategic maneuvering with Ohtani. If Ohtani starts as a designated hitter and later pitches,the Dodgers would lose their designated hitter once his pitching appearance concludes,unless he transitions to a position like the outfield – a position he hasn’t played since 2021.
The umpire’s decision to start the pitch clock as Ohtani exited the dugout, despite his recent at-bat, appeared to adhere strictly to the rule clarification. However, some observers questioned weather the application of the rule was influenced by ohtani’s unique situation and the preceding complaints from opposing teams. The incident underscores the complexities of navigating MLB’s rules in the context of a player like Ohtani, who challenges traditional baseball classifications.
Regardless of the outcome of the game, the situation highlights the ongoing need for clarity and consistent application of rules as MLB continues to evolve with players like ohtani. Further details on the Dodgers can be found at Dodgers on SI.
