Lawyers for Accused in UnitedHealthcare CEO Killing Seek Case Dismissal
MINNEAPOLIS,MN – October 11,2025 – Attorneys representing Luigi Mangione,accused in the shooting death of UnitedHealthcare CEO Dan DePaoli,filed a motion today seeking dismissal of federal charges,alleging prosecutorial misconduct adn insufficient evidence. The filing in U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota escalates the legal battle surrounding the high-profile case and raises questions about the investigation’s handling.
The move comes as scrutiny intensifies over the circumstances surrounding depaoli’s death on September 27, 2025, in Huntersville, North Carolina. Mangione, 61, faces charges of interstate stalking and discharging a firearm during a crime of violence. the defense argues the federal charges represent an overreach, attempting to federalize a local matter and mirroring criticisms leveled against insurance industry practices – specifically, the pursuit of profit over patient well-being - that DePaoli’s company has faced.A dismissal would halt the federal prosecution, possibly leading to state-level charges or a complete resolution of the case.
According to court documents, Mangione’s legal team claims investigators improperly obtained evidence and failed to adequately investigate potential alternative suspects. They allege the prosecution is relying heavily on circumstantial evidence and a narrative built on Mangione’s past disputes with UnitedHealthcare regarding denied claims for his wife’s medical treatment.
“We believe the government has built a case on speculation and a pre-determined narrative, ignoring crucial evidence that points to other possibilities,” stated a spokesperson for Mangione’s defense team. “The charges are an attempt to criminalize a personal grievance and are not supported by the facts.”
DePaoli,63,was fatally shot while cycling near his home. authorities allege Mangione traveled from Minnesota to North Carolina with the intent to harm DePaoli, motivated by ongoing disagreements over healthcare coverage. UnitedHealthcare, a subsidiary of UnitedHealth Group, is one of the largest health insurance companies in the United States, serving over 148 million people.the company has frequently been the target of complaints regarding claim denials and restrictive coverage policies.
