The Economist: Corporate Spin-Offs Are Getting Out of Control
“Three magnificent spin-offs.” That is how the investor Joel Greenblatt describes his children, in the dedication of his book “You Can Be a Stock Market Genius”, which treats buying shares in companies carved out of larger ones as a near foolproof strategy.
The Economist reported on November 18 that corporate spin-offs are getting out of control, and that some are enormously successful — but certainly not all.
The practice is simple to describe and hard to do well. A spin-off takes a division of a company and turns it into a free-standing enterprise, usually by distributing shares to existing owners. In principle, everyone wins.
The parent sheds a business that did not fit; the new company answers to investors who judge it on its own merits; and bosses, who by nature prefer to run bigger enterprises, are forced to focus, the Economist reported.
In practice, the small print does a lot of work. When that machinery runs well, the result can be two companies worth more apart than together. When it runs badly, investors inherit a shrunken parent and an undercapitalised newcomer.
Why do companies keep pulling themselves apart? Pressure, mostly. Spin-offs often take place under pressure from activist investors, who push boards to break up conglomerates and return the pieces to shareholders. Stock analysts, the Economist noted, delight in the simplicity of the cleaved companies, whose accounts become easier to read once a sprawling parent has let a business go its own way.
Hedge-fund traders, for their part, delight in the opposite: the complexity of the separation itself. Index funds must sell the new shares on technical grounds; holders of the parent receive stock they never chose to own. Both produce forced sellers, and forced sellers create mispricing — the very inefficiency that Mr Greenblatt’s strategy exploits.
That is the theory of the trade. The Economist’s verdict on the practice is cooler: some spin-offs are enormously successful, and certainly not all are. A cleaved company is only as good as the business being cleaved. Focus is no cure for a weak market position, thin margins or a shrinking customer base, and the discipline that analysts admire in a separation does not conjure growth where none existed.
For boards weighing a break-up over the coming fiscal quarters, the lesson cuts both ways.
Mr Greenblatt, born in 1957, knows the trade from the inside. In 1985 he started the hedge fund Gotham Capital with $7 million, most of it provided by Michael Milken, and over the following decade it produced annualised returns of 50% after expenses before incentive fees.
Gotham specialised in precisely the “special situations” — spin-offs and corporate restructurings — that his book describes. In 1995 he returned the capital of outside partners, roughly $500 million, and he has since taught value investing to MBA students at Columbia University for more than 20 years.
The strategy, meanwhile, has been in print since Mr Greenblatt published it. “You Can Be a Stock Market Genius” remains dedicated to his wife and their three magnificent spin-offs. Whether the next wave of cleavages produces magnificent ones — or merely smaller companies — is the question the coming spin-off season will have to answer.