Suspect in Hopkins Uber Driver Attack Released on $800,000 Bond
Suspect in a Hopkins Uber driver attack walked out of jail Wednesday after posting an $800,000 bond, FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul reported — a figure prosecutors had recommended and a defense attorney had argued should be no more than $20,000.
Court records show Samit Apurva Patel, 25, was released at 3:55 p.m. on Wednesday, Nov. 18, and will be under electronic home monitoring, per FOX 9. He is charged with attempted second-degree murder and first-degree carjacking in the weekend attack on driver Mohamed Yusuf.
- Patel, 25, posted the $800,000 bond set by Judge Paul Scoggin and was released Wednesday afternoon under electronic home monitoring, court records show.
- Yusuf, a 51-year-old Somali American driver from Blaine, remains hospitalized in critical condition with what the criminal complaint calls a poor prognosis.
- Prosecutors declined to seek a bias enhancement, saying evidence is insufficient to prove the assault was motivated by bias; community leaders have asked the FBI to investigate.
The numbers frame the divide. Prosecutors recommended the $800,000 bail; defense attorney Michael Holland pushed for no more than $20,000, citing Patel’s clean criminal background, college degree and employment in real estate, the Minnesota Star Tribune reported. Scoggin, who set the higher amount, called the allegations “quite chilling and surprising,” according to the Star Tribune, citing the circumstances of the attack and Patel’s lack of a criminal record.
What prosecutors say happened is stark. According to the criminal complaint, Patel strangled Yusuf with his seatbelt, then ran him over with his own car. Police found Yusuf lying in a ditch in Hopkins, FOX 9 reported. He is still at HCMC with life-threatening injuries, and family members say he has been in a coma and has undergone multiple surgeries.
BREAKING: Hennepin County prosecutors charged a Hopkins man Tuesday with attempted second-degree murder and first-degree carjacking in an attack that left Somali American Uber driver Mohamed Yusuf fighting for his life. The defendant, 25-year-old Samit Apurva Patel, remains in… pic.twitter.com/ciE3Qq14TK
Why prosecutors won’t call it a hate crime
The attack raised immediate fears among Muslim leaders and Minnesota’s Somali community that bias motivated it. On Monday, Muslim leaders called for the FBI to investigate, FOX 9 reported. The Council on American-Islamic Relations’ Minnesota chapter hosted a news conference outside HCMC that drew more than 100 people, per the Star Tribune.
Prosecutors stopped short of a bias charge. Minnesota has no separate hate crime statute, but bias motivation can be used as a sentencing enhancement — one that requires proving beyond a reasonable doubt both the crime and the bias behind it.
“There is insufficient evidence to prove to a jury beyond reasonable doubt that a specific bias was the motivation for Mr. Patel’s actions,” the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office said in a statement.
County Attorney Mary Moriarty told reporters on Tuesday that motive is hard to prove. “All we really have was Mr. Yusuf’s brother conveying that the conversation that he heard,” she said. “It’s very difficult to get into somebody’s head and figure out what the motivations are.”
According to the Star Tribune, Jaylani Hussein of CAIR Minnesota relayed that a family member on the phone throughout the ride heard the passenger ask to hear the driver’s name, then say, “I don’t like that name.” Moriarty acknowledged her office has no indication Patel was aware of negative public commentary about Somalis, but added, “I don’t know how you can miss it.”
The assault is confirmed. A Somali Uber driver was attacked by a passenger in Hopkins, MN early Nov 14, suffered serious injuries, and is in a coma per family. Suspect Samit Apurva Patel was arrested nearby and booked for first-degree assault. Local outlets (CBS MN, FOX 9, KSTP)…
What the criminal complaint shows
Patel’s parents called police about 1:20 a.m. Saturday to say their son came home drunk, confused and belligerent, expressing fear about a strange vehicle parked outside. Officers found an unoccupied, damaged SUV in the street with its engine running and vegetation stuck to its underside.
Patel appeared intoxicated and asked officers to arrest him, saying he had done something bad, the complaint states. GPS data from Uber showed Yusuf had picked him up at the Moose Bar and Grill in northeast Minneapolis. Officers found Yusuf’s phone inside the SUV, still connected to a call with the driver’s brother.

Hopkins Police Chief Brent Johnson said investigators are considering all potential motives. “Our responsibility is to follow the evidence, establish the facts and ensure that any criminal charges are supported by the investigation,” he said in a statement.
Who said what on the bias question
FOX 9 centers the court record: the release time, the bond, the monitoring conditions. Moriarty said no federal authorities have contacted her office about the case.
Scoggin’s conditions of release bar alcohol and illicit drug use, per the Star Tribune. Moriarty also said the environment for the state’s Somali neighbors is “absolutely frightening.”
Patel’s next court appearance is set for 9 a.m. on Dec. 16.
A 25-year-old man is facing attempted second-degree murder and first-degree carjacking charges after allegedly attacking Somali-American Uber driver Mohamed Yusuf in Hopkins. Yusuf suffered life-threatening injuries and remains hospitalized. The attack raised concerns about a… pic.twitter.com/6nN26ATyUY
The number that still divides the case
The bond gap — $800,000 versus the $20,000 the defense sought — is a 40-fold spread between what prosecutors argued the allegations warranted and what the defense argued Patel’s record justified. The FBI question, meanwhile, remains open: asked by the Star Tribune whether it is investigating, a spokesman declined to comment.
Yusuf’s family, through the charges, says he “continues to fight for his life, but his prognosis is poor.”
More on Hopkins Uber
A Somali American Uber driver was hospitalized and in a coma after being assaulted by a passenger on Saturday in Hopkins, Minnesota, the driver's family said, as police said investigators were examining whether bias played a role in the attack. https://t.co/ge4y8WQzzY
A Somali American Uber driver, Mohamed Yusuf, was hospitalized and in a coma after being assaulted by a passenger on November 14 in Hopkins, Minnesota, the driver's family said, as police said investigators were examining whether bias played a role in the attack…
Uber passenger charged in brutal assault of Somali American driver in Hopkins https://t.co/I86qzJgr8I
A Somali American Uber driver was hospitalised and left in a coma after being assaulted by a passenger on Saturday in Hopkins, Minnesota, his family said. “A passenger asked his name, told him he didn’t like that name, and then attacked him,” said Suleiman Adan, deputy executive… pic.twitter.com/FQwL4URUYh
Don't let that little bit of reality ruin a perfectly good narrative.