Skip to main content
World Today News
  • Home
  • News
  • World
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Health
  • Technology
Menu
  • Home
  • News
  • World
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Health
  • Technology
Scientists Disagree on Definitions of Science More Than the Public, Study Finds

Scientists Disagree on Definitions of Science More Than the Public, Study Finds

November 22, 2026 Technology Desk Technology

Scientists disagree about what science actually is more than the general public does, a survey of 91 researchers and 99 non-scientists published November 4 in Royal Society Open Science found.

  • The Tech TL;DR: Scientists show less consensus than the public on 18 historical definitions of science.
  • Public views align closer to physicists and biologists than to psychologists or social scientists.
  • Authors warn AI-driven discovery could automate a single narrow conception of scientific method.

Marina Dubova, then a postdoctoral researcher at the Santa Fe Institute, led the study with Princeton University researcher Qiawen E. Liu. Participants evaluated 18 descriptions of science drawn from historical perspectives — including science as detective work, a search for truth, and a mirror reflecting reality — and rarely embraced any single definition without reservations, ScienceDaily reported.

“What was surprising to me was that there was quite a bit of disagreement between scientists, including scientists who are in the same subfield,” Dubova told ScienceDaily. Both groups agreed that curiosity, exploration, and solving mysteries are central to science.

Beyond that common ground, scientists split sharply: some viewed science primarily as a means of discovering objective truths, while others emphasized imagination, personal judgment, and creative decisions. They also disagreed over whether progress depends on following established procedures or improvising as challenges arise, phys.org noted.

Members of the public expressed more consistent views, tending to regard science as a dependable way to discover objective truths through well-defined procedures, while placing less importance on uncertainty and creativity. That idealized picture could shape how people judge research and help explain public frustration when scientists cannot give firm answers or revise conclusions as new evidence emerges, scitechdaily.com reported.

Even scientists cant agree on what scien
Photo: sciencewiredaily.com

The public’s understanding more closely resembled the views of physicists and biologists than those of psychologists and other social scientists. One possible reason is that physics and biology receive greater attention in science education, though Dubova cautioned that explanation remains tentative and requires additional investigation, sciencewiredaily.com reported.

Dubova suspects these differences arise partly because scientists develop their own approaches through experience. Just as chefs can have very different philosophies about preparing food — some following recipes precisely, others improvising instinctively — researchers don’t necessarily share the same ideas about how best to investigate the world, phys.org reported.

Not one of the 18 descriptions won scientists’ complete endorsement, and they frequently held doubts even about concepts they largely endorsed, scitechdaily.com noted.

The findings raise questions for efforts to automate scientific research. As developers build AI systems capable of conducting scientific investigations, Dubova worries that automation could reinforce one narrow conception of how science should work at the expense of other valuable approaches, ScienceDaily reported.

“Don’t take the common understanding of science for granted,” Dubova said. “Always ask. Always be curious about what someone has in mind.” Financial backing came from the Lou Schuyler Seed Grant Fund, created in 2022 to fund exploratory work by early-career scientists; Dubova applied the money to pay participants, scitechdaily.com reported.

Marina Dubova, who completed her Ph.D. in cognitive science at Indiana University in 2024, joined the Santa Fe Institute as a Complexity Postdoctoral Fellow that August. Her dissertation on the cognitive mechanisms of discovery earned the Cognitive Science Society’s Glushko Prize in 2026.

She now directs the Cognitive Epistemology Lab as an assistant professor of psychology at UC Berkeley, where she develops computational models and runs cognitive experiments with scientists to test the foundations of scientific method.

The preprint is available at Royal Society Open Science.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X

Related reading

  • Regeneron Study: Enhertu Plus Bispecific Antibody Clears Tumors in Mice, Triggers Immune Memory
  • Google Introduces New Gemini Camera UI and GIF Creation Feature

Related

Search:

World Today News

World Today News is your trusted source for global journalism — breaking headlines, in-depth analysis, and reporting from around the world.

Quick Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Accessibility statement
  • California Privacy Notice (CCPA/CPRA)
  • Contact
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA Policy
  • Do not sell my info
  • EDITORIAL TEAM
  • Terms & Conditions

Browse by Location

  • GB
  • NZ
  • US

Connect With Us

© 2026 World Today News. All rights reserved. Your trusted global news source directory.
For contact, advertising, copyright, issues email: [email protected]

Privacy Policy Terms of Service