Russia Rejects NATO-Style Security Guarantees for Ukraine, Contradicting Kushner
On November 20, 2026, Russia rejected security guarantees for Ukraine modeled on the mutual-defense provisions of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, directly challenging assertions by American negotiators that Moscow had softened its stance on Western security commitments.
Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said that any arrangement granting Ukraine partial membership or security protections resembling the alliance’s collective-defense framework would cross a firm red line. The declaration exposed a sharp diplomatic divergence just a day after U.S. special envoy Jared Kushner told European leaders in Berlin that American diplomats had made headway in persuading Moscow to accept terms mirroring Article 5 of the NATO treaty.
“We’ve gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept,” Kushner said on Thursday, referring to mutual-defense commitments requiring allies to assist a member under attack, according to International Business Times.
Ryabkov countered those assertions on Friday by dismissing the entire approach. “Even finding a formula for quasi-membership in NATO for Kyiv and searching for some kind of creative solution in this area is an unacceptable option for us,” Ryabkov said, according to Interfax Russia cited by the Kyiv Post.

Diverging Diplomatic Positions
The stark disagreement highlights deep divisions over what postwar safeguards Ukraine might secure following a potential ceasefire. While Washington and European allies explore frameworks to deter future incursions, Moscow insists on maintaining its core demands regarding regional security architecture.
During meetings in Berlin, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European representatives discussed a joint security framework. Proposals included sustained military assistance, a United States-led ceasefire monitoring mechanism, and a European-led multinational force supported by Washington.
Zelenskyy expressed uncertainty over whether Kyiv and Washington share the same interpretation of an Article 5-style arrangement, noting that credible deterrence requires allied forces physically stationed inside Ukraine. Moscow has consistently rejected the deployment of Western military personnel on Ukrainian soil.
Meanwhile, French President Emmanuel Macron argued that Russia should not dictate future security arrangements, calling for discussions on eventual alliance membership for Kyiv to be reopened. Ryabkov responded by asserting that Russia sees no fundamental difference between the alliance and the European Union, which he characterized as pursuing an increasingly militarized and anti-Russian course.
Precedents and Security Concerns
Ukraine’s insistence on binding security guarantees is rooted in the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, under which Kyiv surrendered its Soviet-inherited nuclear arsenal in exchange for assurances from Russia, the United States, and the United Kingdom. Those assurances failed to prevent the 2014 annexation of Crimea and the full-scale invasion launched in February 2022.

Ryabkov said that Moscow expects Ukraine to officially renounce any ambitions of joining the military alliance as a prerequisite for meaningful negotiations on postwar security. Rumored proposals from Russian negotiators have also revived older demands, including the withdrawal of alliance troops from former communist member states to 1997 borders.
Ryabkov, born in Leningrad in 1960, has been Deputy Foreign Minister since 2008 after graduating from the Moscow State Institute of International Relations in 1982.
He led the Russian delegation in the January 2022 Geneva security talks with U.S. Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman, where he stated Russia had no intention of invading Ukraine. Earlier, he served as Minister-Counselor at the Russian Embassy in Washington and headed the Foreign Ministry’s Department of European Co-operation.
Next Steps in Negotiations
Despite the public rejection of Western protection models, diplomatic channels remain active. Ryabkov confirmed that preparations are underway for representatives from Britain, Germany, and France to visit Moscow.
Russian President Vladimir Putin said that Moscow proposed receiving the European envoys to clarify their positions before determining the format for future peace talks. The next round of consultations is expected to take place before the G20 summit scheduled for December 14-15 in Miami, US News America reported.