Pennsylvania Board of Education Rejects Plan to Lower Advanced Test Score Thresholds
The Pennsylvania State Board of Education voted 9-5 on Thursday to reject a proposal that would have lowered the score thresholds required for students to achieve an “advanced” rating on state standardized tests.
The decision halts changes to the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment (PSSA) and Keystone Exams for the 2026 academic year.
Board Rejection of Test Thresholds
The rejected proposal sought to modify how the state evaluates student proficiency, specifically by lowering the point requirements for the “advanced” performance category. While the score needed to be deemed “proficient” would have remained at 1,000, the adjustment aimed to recalibrate metrics that have remained largely unchanged since 2015, the Altoona Mirror reported.
Supporters of the measure, including the Pennsylvania Department of Education, argued that the update was necessary to ensure that performance labels accurately reflect current classroom content and student knowledge, rather than making the assessments easier or harder.
“Our goal throughout this process has always been to make sure that Pennsylvania's standardized test data are meaningful, accurate and relevant to what's actually happening in our classrooms,” said Erin James, press secretary for the Department of Education.

The Pennsylvania State Board of Education decision came after nearly 90 educators participated in a “Standards Validation” process to develop the new scoring standards. Despite this, the board ultimately prioritized concerns regarding the timing and the potential for skewed data.
State Senator Lindsey Williams, who voted against the proposal, stated, “I’m not convinced that 2026, the year when nearly half the students took the test online for the first time and there were tech issues in its administration … is the right year to serve as our baseline going forward,” as reported by Chalkbeat.
Impact on Student Data and Funding
Critics of the plan expressed concerns that altering the scoring metrics would obscure longitudinal data used to determine public school funding and measure academic progress. Rachel Langan, a policy analyst for the Commonwealth Foundation, warned that Pennsylvanians should be suspicious of the changes, noting that the state is “continuously lowering the bar for student success” while obscuring key data points that compare current performance to previous years.
The debate highlights the tension between modernizing assessment tools and maintaining rigorous academic standards.
Proposal Rejection Delays Test Results and School Selection
The rejection of the proposal forces the state to revert to the existing scoring system, which will require the Department of Education to re-run data for the roughly 800,000 students who took the PSSA and Keystone exams, the Inquirer reported. This process is expected to further delay the release of results that are typically provided to districts in August.
The consequences of this delay are particularly acute in Philadelphia, where the school district has already postponed its school-selection window twice. Students applying to competitive magnet schools often require specific PSSA scores to qualify, and the current uncertainty regarding the release of those scores has forced the district to push the application deadline to December 16, according to the Inquirer.

| Metric | Status |
|---|---|
| Board Vote Count | 9-5 Against |
| Annual Student Impact | Over 800,000 students |
| Last Scoring recalibration | 2015 |
| Philadelphia Application Deadline | December 16, 2026 |
Future of State Testing Metrics
While the board rejected the immediate implementation of the new cut scores, some members suggested that a long-term reevaluation is still necessary. “We’ve gone way too long for addressing these in any kind of systematic or thoughtful manner,” said Peter Schweyer, Chair of the House Education Committee, who was the only legislator on the board to vote in favor of the proposal, as noted by Chalkbeat.
The Pennsylvania State Board of Education, created by the General Assembly in 1963 and reestablished in 1988, comprises 21 members who also serve as the State Board of Career and Technical Education.
Seventeen members are appointed by the Governor with Senate consent for six-year terms, while four legislative members hold their seats as long as they chair the House and Senate Education Committees, a structure that placed Rep. Peter Schweyer on the board for Thursday’s vote.
The Department of Education has not yet provided a new timeline for when families and schools can expect the 2026 test results. As districts await the re-run data, school officials must continue to rely on existing metrics to determine course placements for the current academic year.
“The whole purpose of having these assessments is to inform instruction for the coming year, and right now we’re almost halfway through the current year,” said board Vice Chair Carol Aichele, as reported by Chalkbeat.