LSU Student Madison Brooks Rape Trial: Suspects Seek to Block Text Messages
Text messages detailing a mother’s warnings to stay silent are at the center of courtroom battles as a Louisiana man prepares to stand trial for rape according to New York Post.
Desmond Carter, 21, is scheduled to face trial on Dec. 7 on charges of first- and third-degree rape in connection with the 2023 death of 19-year-old Louisiana State University student Madison Brooks, according to Wbrz. Both Carter and Kaivon Washington maintain that their sexual encounters with Brooks were consensual.
Carter’s defense attorneys have filed motions attempting to exclude a wide array of evidence from the state, including frantic mobile phone messages Carter exchanged with co-defendants Casen Carver and Kaivon Washington, as well as Everett Lee, after Brooks died following a night out drinking at Reggie’s Bar in Tigerland.
Counsel for Carter claimed in a September court filing that the inclusion of these messages would infringe upon his client’s Fifth Amendment rights against self-incrimination, according to Internewscast. The court filing does not specify which recipient received each message.
The disputed text messages include statements such as:
Suspect in alleged gang rape of LSU student Madison Brooks wants to ban pink attire from courtroom https://t.co/uNVi90iUB9 pic.twitter.com/pzBlEL7cfY
“my momma told me don’t say nun”
“my momma told me don’t go to no station or not”
“yeah my momma told me just don’t say nun rn”
“me neither my momma said just don’t say nun bc they want us to be witnesses to make there job easier”
“yeah bc my mom said she ain’t lettin them talk to me unless i’m bein charged for sum”
“facts i don’t wanna talk, but casen gave our names all of us”
“well idek if imma be talkin to them or not”
“my momma told me don’t talk at all”
“momma said they can’t come talk to me bc i’m underage.”
Judge Gail Horne Ray has not yet issued a ruling on the request to block the texts. Beyond the messages, the Thursday hearing revolved around multiple other defense motions attempting to exclude evidence.
Defense attorneys asked for Brooks’ death to be excluded from evidence during the trial, an argument the state combatted by stating the information is relevant to help explain why the jury is not hearing testimony from the victim. Defense lawyers also asked to bar the word “victim” from being used to refer to Brooks and tried to exclude testimony from the state’s expert witness on toxicology.
In the meantime, the district attorney’s office is seeking to have Carter’s legal team held in contempt due to a procedural error. Prosecutors state that in a filing regarding whether spectators could wear pink in support of the victim and her family, the lawyer wrote out Brooks’ name instead of using her initials, M.B., which the state argues violates laws protecting the identity of a sex crime victim.
Louisiana State University, the flagship institution of the state’s university system, traces its origins to 1860 when it was founded near Pineville as the Louisiana State Seminary of Learning & Military Academy. Originally modeled after the Virginia Military Institute, the school is still known for its deep-rooted military traditions and the nickname “The Ole War Skule.”
The university eventually moved to its current location in Baton Rouge, where the main campus was formally dedicated in 1926. Today, the institution is classified as a research university with very high research activity and occupies a 650-acre plateau situated along the banks of the Mississippi River.

Family Grief
“Maddie felt safe that night, she thought these were her friends and I think a lot of selfish choices were made that night, and ultimately it led to a horrific ending,” Ashley Baustert, Brooks’ mother, previously told Fox News Digital.