Ghosh: Scam Syndicates Shifting to South Asia, Urges Borderless Enforcement
In a column for CNA published Friday, Singapore-based writer and former foreign correspondent Nirmal Ghosh argues that scam syndicates squeezed out of Southeast Asia are regrouping in South Asia, and he calls for a borderless enforcement response to match.
The piece ran on November 19, a monthly column Ghosh writes for the network.
His core claim rests on a September 2026 briefing note by the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organised Crime (GITOC), where Ghosh sits on the board — he writes in his personal capacity, the column states. The finding is blunt about a shift that has been building since crackdowns across Southeast Asia began in 2025.
“South Asia stands out as a region most significantly affected by trafficking in persons for forced criminality into Southeast Asia, but it is also an emerging operational hub.”
the GITOC briefing note states, as quoted in the column. The note also flags growing convergence between Southeast Asia’s cyber scam operations, South Asia-based recruitment and trafficking networks, and criminal organisations in South Asia already running job and visitor visa scams.
Why the syndicates moved on
Ghosh writes that the large, centralised scam compounds that defined the industry in Southeast Asia are evolving under pressure — splitting into smaller, decentralised units and hunting for jurisdictions with weaker enforcement, CNA reported. His description of the logistics is specific: Sri Lanka drew syndicates early with easy entry visas, reliable high-speed internet and affordable rents, with apartments and villas becoming preferred bases.

Pakistan followed a similar logic, according to the column. Until early 2026 it offered relatively easy visa-on-arrival rules, cheap office space, a large pool of English-speaking young workers and what Ghosh calls gaps in oversight. The accompanying CNA report cites the 2025 Sumsub Global Fraud Index, which ranked Pakistan the most vulnerable of 112 countries to digital fraud.
The evidence on the ground is mounting. Pakistan’s answer to the threat has been structural: after a slow start, the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency became fully operational as an independent authority last year, and there is an ongoing debate over whether provinces should run their own versions of it.
Three raids trace the shift
| Date | Location | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| August 2026 | Gulberg Green, Islamabad | 258 foreigners detained, including 40 Chinese and 170 Vietnamese |
| October 2026 | Rawalpindi | 130 Malaysians detained in a joint Malaysian-Pakistani investigation |
| Since January 2026 | Sri Lanka nationwide | Over 1,100 foreign nationals arrested for alleged cybercrime |
The Rawalpindi raid is the column’s centerpiece. Malaysians — some on valid visas, some expired, according to Malaysian authorities — were detained in a relatively high-end mixed-use apartment and office building on the southern outskirts of the city.
They had reportedly been posing as bank and police officers, telling targets of suspicious transactions and pressuring them to transfer money, CNA reported. Malaysian police said last week a team was being sent to Pakistan to assist.
Pakistani media reported the operation was believed to be run by a Malaysian based in Cambodia, with supervisors in Pakistan.
“franchise displacement model”
— that is how a local expert on organised crime described the arrangement to Ghosh. The raid itself he calls the “smoking gun” for the displacement thesis.

Sri Lanka arrests 1,100 foreigners; India orders WhatsApp action
Sri Lankan police have arrested over 1,100 foreign nationals since the start of 2026, mostly from China, Vietnam and India, for alleged involvement in cybercrime. Officials said the networks were targeting people across Asia. On Monday, November 16, the US Embassy in Colombo announced an FBI team would spend a week in Sri Lanka this month training local investigators, helping to identify victims, trace criminal activity and build stronger cases against online scammers.
“smoking gun”
India’s parallel effort is further along. Its Supreme Court on October 29 ordered WhatsApp and other online platforms to tell the court what measures they are taking to prevent “digital arrest” scams, in which fraudsters pose as police officers to intimidate targets.
The court also pressed for rules requiring financial institutions to cover a victim’s entire loss when their own failure to take reasonable precautions enabled the fraud. In December 2025, India’s Central Bureau of Investigation, acting on FBI information, arrested six alleged leaders of syndicates targeting Americans, and this year has seen dozens of scam operations broken up with thousands of arrests, the CNA report states.

The push for a borderless response
Ghosh’s argument lands on a structural point: scam syndicates, the human trafficking that feeds them, and the money laundering that moves their proceeds do not respect state borders. They run on a borderless digital world and, increasingly, on artificial intelligence. Enforcement, he argues, needs to be equally borderless — with deeper information sharing between agencies across both South and Southeast Asia.
The joint Malaysian-Pakistani investigation into the Rawalpindi case and the FBI’s training work in Colombo are, in his words, encouraging. But he wants such cooperation expanded within the regions themselves, not just between partners outside them, to match what he calls a complex and predatory criminal industry.
The whole piece runs on a warning its author frames late: enforcement that stays inside national borders will keep losing to an industry that doesn’t. As the GITOC note puts it, the dispersal of scam syndicates to South Asia “underscores their fluid nature.”