Florida Election Decided by Coin Toss as Jennifer Lagner Wins Atlantic Beach Seat
Jennifer Lagner won a seat on the Atlantic Beach City Commission after a coin toss on November 13, 2026, breaking a deadlocked race against Lisa Herrold.
For candidates, an election campaign is gruelling where they spend months persuading voters to put their faith in them. Yet Lagner had to rely on a coin flip once election outcomes were published on November 13, as reported by NDTV.
The unusual tiebreaker took place at the Duval County Supervisor of Elections office in Jacksonville, following a machine and manual count of the ballots that left both candidates neck-and-neck, as reported by the New York Post.
Ballots and Recounts
Following the November 3 voting period, tabulation results showed that both Lagner and her opponent Lisa Herrold had each pulled in precisely 3,162 votes. Election officials subsequently ordered a recount for the race for Atlantic Beach City Commission Seat 4, keeping the outcome uncertain while ballots underwent machine and manual verification.
There was also a last-minute possibility that an overseas ballot could break the tie. An overseas ballot arrived at election offices on November 12, but upon opening it, staff found that the participant had left the Atlantic Beach Commission contest unvoted.
The Twenty-Second Showdown
With the deadlock remaining intact, election officials decided to go for a coin toss outside the Duval County Supervisor of Elections office in front of about a dozen spectators. Following guidelines that mandated a best-of-three series—where each candidate selected heads or tails across the first two flips—Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland used his agency’s challenge coin to conduct the toss.

Herrold went first and called heads. The coin landed on tails, giving Lagner the first win.
Lagner then called heads on the second toss, and this time the coin obliged. The coin had to land in the center of a square mat to be ruled official, and with two successful tosses, Lagner was declared the winner. The entire exercise took roughly 20 seconds, and the ultimate tiebreak was not needed as Lagner swept the tosses 2-0.
Duval County History
Because Florida regulations permit tied races to be settled through lots or games of chance, this uncommon procedure stands as an officially sanctioned method to establish the victor. Holland said that it was only the second time in Duval County history that a race had to be decided by a coin flip.
“It hasn’t happened in about 14 years, and never before. So this would be our second tied election in Duval County. Ever? Ever,” Holland said, according to the New York Post.
Back in 2014, a stalemate between Richard Arthur and Rory Diamond during a Neptune Beach City Council election was resolved by drawing numbered ping-pong balls, with Arthur securing the victory by pulling the higher digit.
Community Reactions
“This shows how great and free our country is,” Lagner told Action News Jax.
“I am honored to have the opportunity to serve as your next City Commissioner for Seat 4,” Lagner wrote on Facebook on November 13. “A coin toss was certainly an unexpected and unforgettable way to bring an election to a close! Thank you to Jerry Holland and his entire team for their work throughout this election process.”
Atlantic Beach, a city in Duval County, Florida, is the second largest of the Jacksonville Beaches communities with a population of 13,513 as of the 2020 census. When most of Duval County consolidated with Jacksonville in 1968, Atlantic Beach, along with Jacksonville Beach, Neptune Beach, and Baldwin, remained quasi-independent, maintaining its own municipal government while residents vote in the Jacksonville mayoral election.
The city traces its origins to 1900 when Henry Flagler built the Mayport branch of the railroad and the Continental Hotel, a summer resort with 250 guest rooms; the Town of Atlantic Beach was incorporated in 1926.
“Jen and I have been a part of this community for years… It was meant to be… We’re going to look back at this and realise how unbelievable this was,” said Herrold, the losing candidate.