ECJ Advocate General: Social Networks Not Free When Users Pay with Personal Data
Facebook is not free if users pay with their personal data.
That is the core of the opinion Advocate General Laila Medina delivered at the Court of Justice of the European Union in case C-643/25, a dispute between the German consumer federation Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband and Meta Platforms Ireland, according to Beckmannundnorda.
The Tech TL;DR:
- An ECJ Advocate General argues that handing over personal data for commercial use counts as “payment” under the EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.
- If the Court follows her, Meta and comparable ad-funded platforms could no longer label such services “free” — a blanket prohibition with no case-by-case deception test.
- GDPR compliance does not shield the label: the AG says data protection law and consumer advertising law apply side by side.
The case dates back to February 2015, when Facebook’s signup form in the EU carried the statement “Facebook is and remains free.” The Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband sued, arguing users actually pay for access by surrendering their personal data and consenting to its commercial exploitation.
The German courts dismissed the claim, holding the ban on “free” labels only applies when consumers incur financial costs. The Federal Court of Justice referred the question to Luxembourg, where case C-643/25 is now pending.
Why “payment” reaches beyond money
According to the press release from the Court, Medina reasons that the directive’s text does not clearly restrict payment to money. She reads the different language versions of the directive in light of its context and objectives. The Court has already recognized, she notes, that consideration for a commercial practice can take forms other than money, provided the consideration has economic value and a clear link to the practice.
Personal data surrendered together with consent to its commercial exploitation meets that bar, in her view: it lets a social network operator generate advertising revenue and finance the service. That users retain control over their data does not prevent the transfer from being a form of payment, per the opinion.
Medina points to newer EU legislation as confirmation of the legislator’s intent. The Digital Content Directive and the Consumer Rights Directive both recognize business models in which consumers receive digital services in exchange for personal data rather than money.
Even though some of those acts postdate 2015 and do not change the meaning of the provision at issue, she argues it would be inconsistent to treat the same arrangements as involving consideration under those regimes while allowing the identical services to be advertised as free under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.
Limiting payment to money would also weaken consumer protection in the digital economy, where users may not grasp the economic value of their data or the extent to which it is exploited for advertising, according to the opinion.
Ban applies without deception test
The practical consequence is sharper than a mere labeling rule. Practices prohibited under all circumstances by the directive — including describing a service as free when payment is demanded — do not require an individual assessment of whether the average consumer was actually misled. If the Court adopts that reading, “free” becomes unusable as a marketing claim for any service whose price is data.
Medina rejected Meta’s three counterarguments in turn. That the list of banned practices is exhaustive does not mean its terms must be read narrowly, she found. The GDPR does not displace the directive: data protection law governs lawful and transparent processing, while the directive governs the accuracy of commercial representations, and both apply concurrently.
And the proposed interpretation restricts neither freedom of enterprise nor freedom to provide services — companies remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data; they simply may not call them free when doing so.
What compliance teams should change now
Until the Court rules — an opinion from an Advocate General is not binding on the judges — the operative distinction in the opinion is between data used commercially and data used to run the service.
Under Medina’s proposed reading, only processing exclusively for delivering the service or meeting legal obligations would fall outside “payment.” That boundary maps onto how consent flows are architected: a platform that can demonstrate its data processing is confined to service delivery and statutory duties keeps the “free” label; anything feeding the ad engine does not.
# Audit a TCF consent record for commercial-purpose grants
curl -s https://api.consent-audit.example/v1/consents/$USER_ID \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $TOKEN" | jq '{
purposes: [.purposes[] | {id, name,
commercial: (.name | test("advertis|marketing|profiling"; "i"))}]
}'
Groups following the filings in C-643/25 on the Court’s portal will want to note that the AG’s reasoning treats a service being described as “free” when consumers pay with their personal data and consent to its commercial use as the misrepresentation itself.
Meta relies on legislative defense, awaits ruling
Meta’s core defense was legislative, not factual: the company argued that the exhaustive list of per-se prohibited practices can only be amended by the legislature. Medina’s answer — that exhaustiveness of the list says nothing about how widely its own terms reach — leaves Meta with little room if the Court agrees.
The German Federal Court of Justice, which sent the question to Luxembourg, now waits for the final judgment. The Court follows Advocate General opinions in the majority of cases, though it is not obliged to; the ruling in C-643/25 will be the binding word on whether “Facebook is and remains free” survives EU consumer law.
The case is a familiar arena for the Federation of German Consumer Organisations (Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband, vzbv). Founded in 2000 through the merger of three consumer organisations — including the Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Verbraucherverbände of 1953 — the Berlin-based umbrella body unites the consumer associations of Germany’s 16 federal states and 29 consumer policy organisations, and was a founding member of the European consumer umbrella BEUC.
As a qualified organisation under German law, it brings between 200 and 300 cease-and-desist actions or court cases each year, a track record that made the 2015 suit against Facebook’s signup label a natural fit.
Until then, the burden sits with any ad-funded operator using the word “free” in the EU market — and with the compliance counsel and data protection officers who have to decide whether that word is still defensible on their signup pages.