Dermatologist Recommends Regular Soap Over Antibacterial for Hand Hygiene
Research has not shown any real advantage to using antimicrobial soaps at home, The Washington Post reported. Regular soap and water, worked into a lather for at least 20 seconds, can trap germs and carry them down the drain.
Gallo and Dunnick both recommended regular soap for general hand hygiene. Antibacterial soaps usually contain ingredients such as benzalkonium chloride, benzethonium chloride or chloroxylenol. They can disrupt the skin’s normal microbes, said Richard Gallo, a dermatologist, immunologist and microbiologist and chair of dermatology at the University of California at San Diego.
“You may diminish your skin’s ability to fight those germs. This may even contribute to antibiotic resistance, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. During cold and flu season, regular soap and water remain the standard recommendation. A study comparing plain soap and antibacterial soap found the antibacterial version was not more effective against 20 bacterial strains. Other research suggests the same appears true for viruses. Gallo said antimicrobials used for only a few days are unlikely to cause problems and could theoretically help decrease disease transmission risk within a household. For cuts and scrapes, the CDC recommends rinsing with clean water or saline, then gently washing surrounding skin with soap and water. The World Health Organization instructs not to use antibiotic solutions to wash wounds. She suggests keeping the wound moist with petroleum jelly to aid healing. Unlike other antimicrobials, benzoyl peroxide doesn’t run the risk of leading to antibiotic resistance. It can cause skin irritation, so Dunnick often recommends it as a cleanser rather than a leave-on product. Antimicrobial cleansers also may be used for folliculitis.”