Democratic Lawmakers File Impeachment Articles Against Hegseth; Initial Effort Fails
Democratic lawmakers in the House filed eight articles of impeachment against Secretary of War Pete Hegseth over his handling of the war in Iran, though the initial effort failed after eleven Democrats missed the vote due to Washington traffic.
Thomas Massie Files Eight Articles
The impeachment push came from Representative Thomas Massie, an iconoclastic Kentucky Republican who lost his primary to a Trump-anointed challenger, according to The New Yorker reported. Massie alleged that Hegseth’s actions were “subversive of constitutional government” and trampled on Congress’s war-making authority. No G.O.P. lawmakers besides Massie backed the move. Republicans, Massie observed, “still haven’t broken from the spell of Donald Trump.”
On the morning of the vote, Hegseth gave a press briefing—his first in half a year—describing the effort to remove him as an attack on both the President and the armed forces.
“This is not patriotism—this is sabotage,” he said.
After the vote, through a spokesman, Hegseth declared “total victory,” while Donald Trump lauded the “EXONERATION of a Great American Patriot.” Hakeem Jeffries, the incoming Speaker of the House, has declared himself a “hard yes” on Hegseth’s impeachment if Democrats take over in January.
Historical Precedents in Washington
The situation recalls the morning of March 2, 1876, when Secretary of War William Belknap raced to the White House to see President Ulysses Grant, The New Yorker reported. Admitting that he had accepted financial kickbacks from a merchant he had named to manage a military trading post, Belknap tendered his resignation to Grant in an effort to head off impending impeachment proceedings by the House. The House was undeterred, and Belknap became the first Cabinet official to be impeached, though the Senate failed to summon the necessary two-thirds majority to convict. That obscure precedent regarding whether Congress has power over a person who has left office became front and center during the second impeachment trial of Donald Trump in February 2021.
As a former television commentator for Fox News with a documented background involving sexual misconduct and heavy drinking, Hegseth makes for an appropriate initial target, despite his denials of any wrongdoing.
Having been plainly unsuited for the Department of Defense position, his tenure thus far has merely validated that perspective by sanctioning extrajudicial maritime executions of suspected drug smugglers, purging top military brass, and attempting to penalize Arizona Senator Mark Kelly for reminding troops of their legal right to decline unlawful commands.
Can the new majority successfully manage the tension between holding the administration accountable and delivering tangible results for voters without appearing fixated on political payback?
Representative Thomas Massie, a libertarian Republican who has represented Kentucky’s 4th congressional district since 2012, filed the impeachment articles against Secretary of War Pete Hegseth over unauthorized hostilities in Iran and extrajudicial killings.
Massie has a long history of breaking with party leadership and President Donald Trump, driven by his staunch opposition to federal spending increases, interventionism, and warrantless surveillance programs—a record that earned him the nickname “Mr. No” and frequent clashes with his own party.