Cricket Australia Lacks Appetite for Truth in Sandpapergate Scandal, Argues Scotty Stevenson
In a column for 1News, TVNZ Sport Presenter Scotty Stevenson argues that Cricket Australia has once again shown “no appetite for the truth” over the 2018 sandpapergate ball-tampering scandal, after the governing body on Wednesday ruled out a fresh investigation and instead announced an independent forum for players and staff from that tour.
Stevenson, writing in an opinion piece published by 1News, places the blame squarely on the organisation rather than the players. He argues the crisis stems from the original 2018 review, which he says was conducted in four days by then-executive Pat Howard and then-head of integrity Iain Roy, and he calls it “staggering” that Usman Khawaja was never even questioned by the original investigators.
“Cricket Australia put expediency above responsibility, a game of cricket above its duty to cricket,” Stevenson writes. “This is why it finds itself here today. Not because Cam Bancroft scratched the side of a cricket ball, but because the organisation he represented failed in its duty to discover the truth behind that act.”
Another earthquake in Australian cricket with the Bancroft revelations. They have no option now but to address the issue directly. A forum to express thoughts with no further action is now untenable. This is one of Australian cricket's biggest moments and just requires them to do…
His column ran hours after Cricket Australia CEO Todd Greenberg and interim chairman David Boon told media in Hobart that the organisation would not reopen the investigation.
Instead, Boon said the forum would let those involved “share their experiences and their perspectives,” adding, “We believe it is time for a circuit-breaker. This is not about litigating the past.” Participation is voluntary, the CA board will decide what conclusions are made public, and Greenberg hopes the process wraps up by Christmas, 1News reported.
Greenberg rules out “perfect truth”
Stevenson takes aim at Greenberg’s framing of the forum’s purpose. “Someone’s version of events will contradict someone else’s version of events so looking for the perfect truth doesn’t exist, and we’re not chasing that,” Greenberg told reporters, according to 1News. The columnist suggests the language of “versions of events” and “stories” sits a long way from any kind of truth, perfect or otherwise.
The article by Bancroft on @cricinfo reveals what many of us have insisted post Khwaja's book release: @patcummins30 has been lying repeatedly. He is NOT a leader! After throwing teammates under the bus twice before, he did it again in the press conference a few days back. Not…
The timing matters. Hours after that press conference, Cameron Bancroft published a 4,000-word statement in The West Australian, reported by The Guardian and the NZ Herald, claiming the entire team knew about plans to use sandpaper to tamper with the ball during the Test series against South Africa, supporting claims made by former team-mate Usman Khawaja.
Bancroft wrote that when questioned in Cricket Australia’s original investigation, “I did not give a complete and truthful account,” and that he withheld details “to protect Cricket Australia’s investigation and not implicate others around me.” He said Cummins’ press conference last week was “the final straw” and left him feeling “angry, betrayed and alone.”
Bancroft’s account corroborates Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr, released last week, in which the retired batter alleged the whole squad knew. David Warner backed Khawaja publicly, and Chadd Sayers, the 12th man at Cape Town, told Australian radio station SEN on November 15: “I am comfortable sitting here that I believe everyone in that side knew what was going on and what was being used.”
Against that, Test captain Pat Cummins told reporters he did not know sandpaper was going onto the field and called Khawaja’s claims “complete and utter nonsense.” According to the NZ Herald, Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon have all publicly denied awareness of the plan. Cummins’ management said on Wednesday there was “nothing in the [Bancroft’s] statement that hasn’t been answered,” Sky Sports reported.
A four-day review, eight years of fallout
Stevenson’s central argument is that the original probe was never built to find the truth. He notes the 2018 investigation concluded in four days, suspended only Smith, Warner and Bancroft, and let the rest of the squad play the next Test.
The forum now on offer, he argues, repeats the pattern: no compulsion to participate, no new sanctions, and the board deciding what the public gets to see. “I can go in there and say something but then the board can decide they’re not going to release that,” Khawaja said.

Greenberg confirmed to reporters, in remarks reported by Stuff, that the original investigation will not be made public and did not examine whether sandpaper was used in other Tests of that series. Bancroft, for his part, has committed to attending the forum, writing in his statement that “transparency is a way to acknowledge our respect for cricket.”
Veteran Australian cricket journalist Peter Lalor told ABC News Breakfast, in an interview cited by Stevenson, that the episode feels like a rewind: “it’s almost like we’re back in 2018. This was buried in a shallow grave and eight years later we’re starting to find out the truth, and it’s a lot worse than we thought.”
The column lands amid broader calls for structural answers rather than blame. Former Australia captain Greg Chappell wrote on Cricinfo that the ICC should give players clearer guidance on ball management and a consistent scale of penalties, so “a sanction doesn’t depend on which board is in the spotlight.”
The stakes are not abstract. Australia play England in a five-match T20I series, beginning on Saturday in Melbourne, before further matches in Carrara (November 24), Brisbane (November 27), Sydney (November 29) and Canberra (December 2). The Test side are next in action against New Zealand in Perth from December 9-13, with further Sandpapergate headlines likely in the days and weeks leading up to that four-match series.
Cummins’ captaincy now faces severe scrutiny, per the NZ Herald, and the sport’s sponsors, broadcasters and match-day partners in Australian cricket will be watching how a governance crisis of this vintage affects the commercial footing of a home summer.
Stevenson closes his column on the ledger: “Cricket Australia had eight years to make this right and now they want a month longer, to keep being wrong. That’s the truth. Or, at the very least, that’s one version of it.”
Disclaimer: The insights provided in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute medical advice or sports betting recommendations.