Consumer NZ Ranks NZ Retailers: Noel Leeming Worst for Misleading Sale Labels, Briscoes Best
“Red hot deals” at five of New Zealand’s biggest retailers often were not the bargains their labels promised, according to a 12-week price-tracking study by Consumer NZ covering 13 products, with Noel Leeming ranked worst and Briscoes first.
1News reported the watchdog’s findings on Thursday. Researchers followed sale prices and promotional language across the five retailers for 12 weeks and found labels such as “Mega Deal” and “Price Smash” sometimes attached to prices that were not the lowest on record for the product.
“There may be a discount, but it’s not perhaps as good as consumers are led to believe,” Consumer NZ research lead Rebecca Styles said.
She said retailers risked breaching the Fair Trading Act if customers were misled — a suggestion Noel Leeming’s chief executive rejected outright.
The mega deal that was a meagre deal
Noel Leeming finished last in Consumer NZ’s rankings, which the watchdog based on how easy it was for shoppers to spot a genuine sale. 1News reported the retailer was “heavy-handed” with sale promises.
“It’s impossible to know which promotional label represents the biggest opportunity to save,” Styles said.
One example stood out. A Breville coffee machine was advertised as a “Mega Deal” for $869 — the highest price Consumer NZ recorded for the machine during the entire 12-week study.
“The mega deal was actually a meagre deal,” Styles said.
Consumer NZ
Noel Leeming chief executive Jason Bell pushed back. He said the coffee machine regularly featured in promotions and the “Mega Deal” price was still among the best available on the market at the time.
“We are confident this is not a breach of the Fair Trading Act or misleading, as it was just positioned as a deal, we did not claim a specific saving,” Bell said.
Other retailers had not yet responded to questions from 1News.
Where the labels misfired
The middle of the rankings told its own story. At JB Hi-Fi, a Breville Barista Express coffee machine was advertised “On Sale” at $600, 1News reported. Weeks later the same machine appeared as a “Red Hot Deal” at $698, and also at $848 — each a discount from its highest tracked price, but with labels that gave little indication of actual savings.
Farmers placed second, yet some labels confused. A washing machine carried a “great price” tag through the full 12 weeks while its price swung from $1248 to $1669. A Samsung heat-pump dryer was labelled a “great price” at both $1399 and $1989.
Harvey Norman had cut its use of promotional labels since being criticised in a similar Consumer NZ investigation last year, but the watchdog still found deals that were not the best on offer. A handheld garment steamer was $34 cheaper unlabelled, and an air fryer was $10 cheaper without a “birthday deal” or “hot deal” tag.
Why Briscoes came out on top
Briscoes earned first place because its sale prices were generally clearly cheaper than usual prices, prices returned to full between promotions, and it used less promotional language than competitors.
“What sets Briscoes apart from the other stores is that prices don’t fluctuate as much,” Styles said.
Cheapest overall was another matter. Consumer NZ noted a Ninja air fryer fell to $125 at Briscoes, while the same product later dropped to $97 at Noel Leeming.
Why the labels work
AUT marketing lecturer Dr Jessica Vredenburg told 1News sales language is designed to create excitement and urgency.
“Some of these words, some of the colours that come along with it actually activate the reward centres in our brain,” she said. “So you feel like you’ve won something if you’ve gotten a deal.”
She said shoppers often do not know the usual price of big-ticket items such as appliances and electronics, making genuine value harder to judge.
Consumer NZ’s advice: track prices of items on your radar, use price-tracking tools, and compare across retailers before buying. It also warned against assuming Black Friday automatically brings the year’s lowest prices.
“Sometimes the language doesn’t actually match the level of saving that people are getting,” Styles said.
Consumer NZ, an independent non-profit advocacy organisation established in 1959, has long campaigned against misleading promotions. In 2023 it complained to the Commerce Commission with 600 examples of supermarket pricing and promotional errors, and in May 2025 the commission filed criminal charges against Woolworths NZ and two Pak’nSave stores over potential Fair Trading Act breaches.
The watchdog is funded primarily by member subscriptions and is known for its quarterly magazine, Consumer, a 2025 Voyager Media Awards finalist.
Whether the Fair Trading Act question reaches regulators remains unresolved — and the retailers who have not yet answered 1News’ questions have not said.