Toilet Cleaner Test: Aldi, DM, and Edeka Brands Top Stiftung Warentest Ratings
Table of Contents
Dortmund, Germany - August 19, 2025 - Consumers seeking effective yet affordable toilet cleaning solutions should look no further than discount retailers, according to a recent evaluation by Stiftung warentest. The autonomous consumer association tested 19 toilet gels, finding that budget-pleasant options from Aldi, DM, and Edeka outperformed well-known brands in both cleaning power and environmental impact.
Test Methodology and Key Findings
Stiftung warentest’s rigorous testing process involved weighing the weight loss of 300 marble slices after exposure to each cleaner, assessing adhesive properties, evaluating material compatibility, and examining environmental considerations.Price points ranged from 10 to 40 cents per 100 milliliters. The results revealed a notable disparity in performance, with some established brands falling short of expectations.
Aldi’s Clinair Fresh Lemon, DM’s Ocean Freshness, and Edeka’s Gut & Cheap Lemon shared the top spot, earning a “good” rating. These products demonstrated reliable lime removal capabilities and a favorable environmental profile.
Pro Tip: Consider the environmental impact of your cleaning products. Choosing eco-friendly options can contribute to a healthier planet.
Disappointing Results from Established Brands
Rossmann Domol Urinstein & Kalklöser achieved the strongest cleaning effect, dissolving nearly 20 times more lime than the lowest-performing products. However, its higher price point of 17 cents per 100 milliliters and increased water stress prevented it from achieving the top overall score, earning a “good” (2.0) rating.
WC-Antal Active Gel Accompany Gel and 00 zero zero WC Active Gel received “deficient” ratings. Both brands underperformed in lime removal and carried a higher price tag than the test winners. Toilet Duck commands 35 cents per 100 milliliters, while 00 zero zero costs 31 cents.
Did you know that the effectiveness of a toilet cleaner isn’t always tied to its price? This test proves that affordable options can deliver exceptional results.
Dosage and environmental Considerations
The study also highlighted inconsistencies in recommended dosage amounts among manufacturers. While Aldi suggests 15 milliliters per cleaning, Domestos recommends 80 grams. Testers established a realistic average of 40 grams per submission for consistent comparison. Many cleaners contain organic acids like citric acid, which break down readily in wastewater treatment plants. However, the presence of surfactants requires careful consideration due to their potential impact on aquatic ecosystems (U.S. environmental Protection Agency).
| Brand | Product | Rating | Price (per 100ml) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aldi | Clinair Fresh Lemon | Good | €0.10 |
| DM | Ocean Freshness | Good | €0.10 |
| Edeka | Gut & Cheap Lemon | Good | €0.10 |
| Rossmann | Domol Urinstein & Kalklöser | Good | €0.17 |
| WC-Antal | Active Gel Accompany gel | Deficient | N/A |
| 00 zero zero | WC Active Gel | Deficient | €0.31 |
the Evolving Landscape of Cleaning Products
Consumer demand for sustainable and eco-friendly cleaning solutions is steadily increasing. Manufacturers are responding by developing products with biodegradable ingredients and reduced packaging. The focus is shifting towards minimizing environmental impact without compromising cleaning performance.This trend is expected to continue as consumers become more aware of the long-term consequences of their purchasing decisions.
Frequently Asked Questions about Toilet Cleaners
- Q: What is the most significant factor when choosing a toilet cleaner?
A: Effectiveness in removing limescale and stains, combined with environmental considerations, are key factors.
- Q: Are homemade toilet cleaners as effective as commercial products?
A: Some homemade solutions, like baking soda and vinegar, can be effective for light cleaning, but may not match the power of specialized cleaners.
- Q: How frequently enough should I clean my toilet?
A: A thorough cleaning once a week is generally sufficient, but more frequent cleaning might potentially be necessary for high-traffic bathrooms.
- Q: What are surfactants and why are they a concern?
A: Surfactants are cleaning agents that can harm aquatic life if they enter waterways. Choosing products with biodegradable surfactants is recommended.
- Q: Does the price of a toilet cleaner always reflect its quality?
A: No, as demonstrated by Stiftung Warentest’s findings, affordable options can often deliver comparable or even superior results.
This latest report from Stiftung Warentest provides valuable insights for consumers seeking the best value in toilet cleaning products. By prioritizing affordability and environmental responsibility, shoppers can maintain a clean and hygienic bathroom without breaking the bank.
We hope this article has been helpful! Please share it with your friends and family, and let us know your thoughts in the comments below. Don’t forget to subscribe to our newsletter for more insightful news and updates.
