BBC Sport: Sandpapergate Scrutiny Reaches Pat Cummins Before NZ Test
Pat Cummins was supposed to walk out unchallenged as Australia’s captain for the first Test against New Zealand in Perth on December 9.
Instead, the sandpapergate spotlight has landed squarely on him, after his agent repeated his client’s version of events in the past 24 hours, BBC Sport reported.
Why the questions finally reached the captain
The reason the scrutiny has reached Cummins is simple, according to BBC cricket correspondent Jonathan Agnew. He argues the idea that Cameron Bancroft, the least experienced batsman in the side, used sandpaper on the ball against South Africa without the bowlers knowing has never made sense.
“It has never seemed remotely plausible to me, as a former bowler, that the bowlers didn’t know what was happening in Cape Town in 2018. It just doesn’t seem possible,” Agnew wrote in the column carried by BBC Sport. “Therefore, this day of reckoning was always going to come.”
“100% wrong” and “utter nonsense”
Cummins has answered publicly once. Speaking to the media on November 12, the Australia captain called claims made by Usman Khawaja over the sandpaper scandal “100% wrong” and “utter nonsense,” according to BBC Sport’s report. His agent has since repeated the captain’s account in the last 24 hours.
What makes the captaincy question matter now is the calendar. Cummins is still slated to lead Australia against New Zealand in Perth on December 9, and there is, per BBC Sport, no obvious suggestion he has considered resigning or that he will be sacked. Cricket Australia has backed him throughout.
That support stands against a different concern: the build-up. Agnew, in the analysis syndicated by Yahoo Sport, writes it is difficult to see how the lead-up will be anything other than a circus, dominated by questions about sandpaper, who knew what and who said what to whom.

A captain unlike his predecessors
Cummins is not a typical Australian captain, Agnew notes. He is not abrasive, and when he says he has worked hard to correct the image of the team, he is credible. Yet Agnew points to a missed opportunity: the Jonny Bairstow stumping in the 2023 Ashes Test at Lord’s, which Cummins chose not to treat as a line in the sand.
The captain’s authority also rests on a job with unusual weight. Agnew describes the Australia captaincy as often joked to be the second-most important job in the country, behind only the prime minister.
The Perth Test on December 9
If Cummins walks out at Perth’s Optus Stadium in front of a home crowd, the reaction will be the litmus test, per BBC Sport. The venue sits in Bancroft’s home city, in the same state as the newspaper that first published his 4,000-word testimony.
The match also carries enormous significance in Perth: the first Test against New Zealand there looks set to be a build-up dominated by questions about sandpaper, who knew what and who said what to whom.
Even if Cummins gets through that week, Agnew expects the Australian media to keep pressing. He calls this one of the biggest stories in the history of Australian sport, and says the press will keep at it until they feel they have the truth.
The Ashes question at Trent Bridge
The longer horizon is next summer’s Ashes. Agnew sets the bar plainly: if Cummins is tossing the coin at Trent Bridge on June 18, then he is extraordinarily resilient. Right now, he writes, he cannot imagine that happening.
The captain has said he never wants to talk about sandpaper again, a stance Agnew calls ludicrous given what an England tour brings: media scrutiny and constant baiting from the crowds. Cummins will have to decide whether he has the stomach for it.
There is a defined way out. Agnew sketches a resignation without an admission of guilt, on the grounds that the speculation has become a distraction for the team and the pressure is taking a toll on family life, with pictures circulating of Cummins being confronted outside his home overnight in Australia.
Such a move could also take heat off the other bowlers, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon. Cummins could continue in the ranks, as David Warner and Steve Smith did before him.
Players caught in this kind of sustained scrutiny, in Agnew’s telling, weigh their careers against speaking up, and only feel free to talk once their time as international cricketers has ended or neared its end.
Who else is left exposed
Whether Cummins stays or goes, Agnew writes, questions remain for others who were in Cape Town, for Cricket Australia and for the wider culture of the sport. Looking back at 2018, he sees an attitude in the camp that they were fireproof and could get away with anything.
He credits the team’s then media manager, Kate Hutchison, who according to Bancroft made a stand about what was going on and understood what would happen if the Australians were caught. He also names two coaches who were supposed to guide and protect young men: Darren Lehmann, now in his position at Northamptonshire, and David Saker, who has recently been working with England.
Cricket Australia, Agnew writes, has seemed reluctant to get involved. The board’s approach of letting individuals “tell their truth” behind closed doors is, in his judgment, dead in the water. His closing demand is sharper: “What about telling THE truth? Nothing else is good enough.”
Cricket Australia, the body whose handling of the affair Agnew condemns, traces its origins to the Australian Board of Control for International Cricket, formed in 1905 after administrators moved to take control of lucrative tours from the players themselves. Its first meeting was held at Wesley College in Melbourne on 6 May 1905, with the New South Wales and Victorian associations as foundation members; South Australia’s delegates refused to join because the structure denied players any representation.
The company was incorporated in 1982 and is governed by nine independent directors, with six member organisations covering the states. Australia, whose men played in the first-ever Test match against England in 1877, has been a full member of the International Cricket Council since its inception in 1909.
December 9 in Perth is fixed. The crowd response is the measure Agnew names, and between now and then every press conference will be about sandpaper rather than cricket.