Despite overwhelmingly negative reviews, the dark fantasy film Arthur & Merlin: Knights of Camelot has risen to prominence on Prime Video, currently ranking among the platform’s top ten most-watched titles. The film, starring Richard Brake-known for his role as the Night King in Game of thrones-is drawing viewers despite widespread critical disapproval, highlighting a disconnect between professional assessments and audience engagement.
Directed by Giles Alderson and initially filmed in 2020, Arthur & Merlin: Knights of Camelot presents a grim take on the Arthurian legend. The story follows a weary King Arthur’s return to a crumbling kingdom after years of conflict with the Roman Empire, forcing him to once again defend Camelot with the aid of Merlin. This iteration of the myth appears to be resonating with audiences drawn to its darker tone and Brake’s performance, even as critics pan its execution.
Currently, the film holds a mere 12% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, with no official critic rating available. Common Sense Media described the film as “a slowly paced Arthur tale with weak special effects and a listless script.” Another review characterized it as “cheap fantasy that fails to breathe new life into the familiar story.”
Though, some viewers have found merit in the film.one audience member commented,”Not the best Arthur film,but still entertaining due to its dark tone and Richard Brake as Merlin.” Susanna Norbiato of Loud and Clear Reviews offered a more positive assessment, stating the film “offers a number of captivating food for thought, which distinguish the film from the origin of the myth and which can provide an interesting viewing experiance.”
Released directly to streaming, bypassing a theatrical run in the Netherlands, Arthur & Merlin: Knights of Camelot‘s success demonstrates the power of recognizable actors and a compelling, if bleak, premise to attract viewers, even in the face of ample criticism. The film’s current position in Prime Video’s top ten suggests a continued appetite for darker interpretations of classic tales.
