AI Tools Unreliable for Black Friday Deals, Tests Show Hallucinated Prices
In a column for The Washington Post, Geoffrey Fowler argues that generative AI tools remain unreliable for Black Friday bargain hunting, citing hallucinated prices and limited retailer access as primary risks for shoppers.
Fowler tested ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity and found that the chatbots frequently invented prices, recommended out-of-stock items and could not reach major retailers that block their crawlers.
Fowler writes that the tools “hallucinate prices” and “make up deals that don’t exist.” He adds that “retailers like Amazon and Best Buy block AI agents from seeing their prices,” leaving shoppers with a partial view of the market.
A week before Black Friday, the BBC asked ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini to find a 55-inch television under £400. ChatGPT suggested a TCL model priced at £399 that was actually £549, and an LG OLED listed at £1,100 that exceeded the budget. Alexa, limited to Amazon’s own catalog, returned correct prices but acknowledged it could not search rival stores.

Retailer blocking compounds the blind spots.
Adobe data cited by ReFiBuy shows AI-referred traffic to U.S. retail sites grew 62 percent year over year in July and converted 60 percent higher than non-AI traffic. Salesforce forecasts that 20 percent of all 2026 holiday e-commerce traffic will originate from AI chat agents. Salesforce also forecasts that Cyber Week sales will hit a record $357 billion with help from AI.
Yet Fowler concludes that shoppers should treat AI as a research starting point, not a buying agent. “Use AI to brainstorm gift ideas and learn product categories,” he writes, “but verify every price and stock status on the retailer’s own site before you spend a dollar.”
The Washington Post, founded in 1877 and purchased by Eugene Meyer out of bankruptcy in 1933, printed the Pentagon Papers in 1971 and broke the Watergate scandal that led to President Richard Nixon’s 1974 resignation. The Graham family sold the paper to Jeff Bezos’s Nash Holdings for US$250 million in 2013; it now operates foreign bureaus in London and Seoul and had 2.5 million digital subscribers in 2023.

Sam Callender, SEO principal at PMG, said: “In 2026, AI’s holiday gift list may start forming before a shopper ever asks for one.”
Keep reading
- Costa Rica Consumer Groups Blame Irresponsible Lending for 776,000 Court Cases
- Manchester United Owe Other Clubs £416 Million in Outstanding Transfer Fees
- Tariffs Added 2.9 Points to Goods Inflation, About 0.6 to All Prices (daybreakwire.com)
- Cleveland Clinic Tests Virtual Reality for Cancer Distress (newsdirectory3.com)