Costa Rica Consumer Groups Blame Irresponsible Lending for 776,000 Court Cases
Costa Rica’s consumer watchdogs told lawmakers this week that 776,000 active judicial collection cases prove the country’s credit crisis stems from irresponsible lending, not interest-rate caps.
Representatives from the Market and Consumer Rights Observatory (OMERCON) and the Association for the Defense of Financial Consumers (APRODECO) appeared before the Permanent Ordinary Commission on Economic Affairs on November 17 to oppose a legislative push to raise maximum interest rates, El Mundo CR reported.
Jaime Mora and Yeikol Zúñiga of OMERCON, joined by Luis Vives of APRODECO, argued that OECD members such as France, Italy, and Japan maintain rate ceilings while enforcing a legal duty for lenders to verify a borrower’s repayment capacity, according to El Mundo CR. Costa Rica lacks that obligation, they said, allowing lenders to profit from high-default portfolios because interest collected from performing loans covers losses on bad ones.
“The lender externalizes the cost of risk — transfers it to the debtor, their family, the judiciary, and society — and keeps the profit,” the organizations told the commission. “That is not an efficient market. It is a business model built on the suffering of others.”
The groups presented a five-point legislative package. The first measure would sanction irresponsible lending by stripping lenders of the right to collect interest if they failed to verify solvency, aligning with the European Union’s Directive 2023/2225.
A second proposal would empower judges to apply prescription of debt ex officio, clearing credit records at the National Credit Information Center (CIC) without requiring debtors to hire lawyers. The organizations estimate this would remove roughly half the judicial system’s collection caseload.
Third, they urged creation of a National Guarantee System for responsible consumption credit — appliances, health emergencies, education — citing models in France, the United Kingdom, and South Korea. With a public guarantee, they said, a borrower paying 51 percent today could access credit at 15 to 17 percent.
Fourth, a national refinancing plan would require original creditors to offer distressed borrowers reduced rates, extended terms, and forgiveness of accrued penalties and legal costs, rather than selling portfolios to collectors at 10 to 20 cents on the dollar.
The final measure calls for a Financial Consumer Protection Law benchmarked to OECD standards.
The witnesses challenged the argument that rate caps drive borrowers to informal “gota a gota” loan sharks. They contended the causality runs in reverse: irresponsible over-indebtedness leads to default, credit-record damage, expulsion from the formal system, and only then to informal lending. Raising caps, they said, would accelerate that cycle rather than interrupt it.
“Eliminating the cap does not solve that cycle. It feeds it,” the representatives said. “It gives the formal system the tools to over-indebted the population even more aggressively, with the certainty that the state will not intervene.”
The commission has not set a date for voting on the proposed rate increase or the consumer groups’ counter-proposals.