A Japanese idol group, Planck Stars, is facing widespread criticism after performing in swimsuits at the Sapporo Snow Festival on February 8, despite sub-zero temperatures and heavy snowfall. The performance, described by some as “abuse,” has prompted an apology from the group’s agency, though many observers have deemed it insincere.
Photos and videos of the performance quickly circulated on social media platforms, including X (formerly Twitter), garnering over 13 million views and sparking a fierce debate. Critics have questioned the agency’s motives, suggesting the event was a deliberately provocative marketing tactic. Concerns have been raised about the potential for hypothermia and the appropriateness of the performance given the family-oriented nature of the festival.
Planck Stars, categorized as an “underground idol” group based in Hiroshima, primarily performs at smaller venues and events, rather than mainstream media platforms. The group’s agency issued a statement on February 9th, explaining that the outfit was chosen by a member without prior consultation. The statement apologized for any “concern and discomfort” caused by the performance and pledged to improve safety measures at future events. Although, this apology has been met with skepticism, with many accusing the agency of prioritizing publicity over the well-being of its performers.
The controversy surrounding the Sapporo Snow Festival performance is not an isolated incident for Planck Stars. The group has a history of controversial “pranks” and antics, reflecting their self-described image as “free-spirited delinquents.” Past incidents include stepping on a fan, hammering the ceiling of a venue, spitting watermelon seeds into a fan’s mouth, and forcing a fan to drink dishwashing liquid.
In 2022, the group held a competition among its members, with the winner receiving a bicycle and the member selling the fewest concert tickets facing a peculiar consequence: debuting in an “AV.” Initial interpretations led to the belief that the losing member would be forced to appear in adult films. However, the agency later clarified that “AV” referred to an “animal video,” a distinction that did little to quell the outrage.
Despite frequent changes in its lineup, Planck Stars continues to release music and stage provocative events. The latest incident, however, appears to have significantly amplified public criticism, leading to questions about the long-term viability of the group’s controversial approach to entertainment. Online commenters have expressed feelings ranging from discomfort to outrage, with some accusing the agency of exploitation and abuse. The agency has not responded to requests for further comment beyond its initial apology.
