11 Delicious Thanksgiving Dessert Alternatives to Pumpkin and Apple Pie
Serious Eats published a roundup of 11 Thanksgiving desserts that move beyond pumpkin and apple pie, highlighting pear, cranberry, sweet potato, pecan, walnut, maple, chocolate and caramel flavors.
The collection includes cakes, flan, pastries and bread pudding designed to serve as showstopping alternatives to the traditional holiday standards.
The lineup opens with a pear upside-down cake described as a “sophisticated alternative” with a tender, warmly spiced crumb, best served with crème fraîche or whipped cream. A cranberry upside-down cake follows, its “glossy, jewel-toned cranberries” balancing tartness against sweet toffee notes, recommended warm with vanilla ice cream.
For smaller gatherings, a pecan-cheesecake hybrid combines a creamy cheesecake base with crunchy pecans and glossy caramel. A simple chocolate mousse uses high-quality 70% bittersweet cacao and can be made well in advance, portioned into glasses or a large serving bowl.
A giant éclair replaces individual pastries with a single choux ring filled with vanilla crème mousseline and topped with chocolate glaze, which the author notes “makes the process far less tedious.”

A double-caramel flan features a blender-assembled custard baked in a water bath to stay “tender and supple.” A walnut cake layered with maple–cream cheese frosting offers a “deep toffee-like flavor,” while mini pecan pies deliver “nutty, gooey goodness” without a full-slice commitment.
Two sweet-potato entries round out the list: a pie where the vegetable simmers in milk and cream with cinnamon sticks, whole nutmeg and vanilla bean, and a “statuesque cheesecake” blending roasted sweet potatoes with cream cheese and Lyle’s Golden Syrup to prevent crystallization. A banana bread pudding folds mashed bananas and walnuts into a custardy base for “little pockets of sweet fruit and nutty crunch.”
A giant éclair replaces individual pastries with a single choux ring filled with vanilla crème mousseline and topped with chocolate glaze, which the author notes “makes the process far less tedious.” The double-caramel flan uses a blender-assembled custard baked covered in a water bath to stay “tender and supple,” while a walnut cake layered with maple–cream cheese frosting offers a “deep toffee-like flavor.”
A sweet potato cheesecake blends roasted sweet potatoes and cream cheese in a food processor, with Lyle's Golden Syrup preventing crystallization and highlighting the dairy's richness.
Serious Eats includes a promotional message urging readers to “Never Lose a Recipe Again!” by using the MyRecipes app. The app allows users to save and organize favorites from anywhere, including Instagram and TikTok, in one convenient place.
Yahoo republished the Serious Eats roundup with credited photography for each dessert, including work by Robby Lozano, Mateja Zvirotić Andrijanić, Morgan Hunt Ward, Amanda Suarez, Jen Causey, Vicky Wasik and Debbie Wee.