Judge Rules Seizure of Immigration Lawyer’s Phone at Boston Airport Likely First Amendment Retaliation
A federal judge in Massachusetts ruled that immigration agents likely retaliated against attorney Andrew Lattarulo for his public criticism of immigration policies when they seized his phone without a warrant at Boston Logan International Airport in September 2025. U.S. District Judge Allison D. Burroughs issued an injunction on November 13 blocking the government from searching the copied data, finding Lattarulo likely to succeed on his First Amendment claim.
What happened at Logan Airport?
Lattarulo, a co-owner of Georges Cote LLP, returned from a weekend trip to Aruba on September 28, 2025, and was met at the gate by three CBP agents and one HSI officer. They seized his cell phone without a warrant and downloaded a complete copy of its data, returning the device eight days later, according to court filings cited by Techdirt.
The data includes confidential attorney-client communications and remains in an unreadable format, though the government intends to convert and search it if permitted.
His law firm partner, Georges Cote, returned to Boston on September 27 — one day earlier — and passed through customs without incident, a disparity the court found significant.
Why does the judge call it retaliation?
Judge Burroughs wrote there is “no dispute” that Lattarulo’s Instagram videos — which explain immigrants’ rights and criticize government policies — are protected by the First Amendment. The court found the government adopted a “highly unusual investigative method” after Lattarulo spoke out, Techdirt reported.
HSI had been investigating the firm for allegedly employing unauthorized workers. Audai Cote, who handles I-9 verification for the firm, was served a notice of inspection in September 2025.
After the firm produced documents, the government gave it less than three days to respond to a notice of suspect documents — trimming the stated ten-day window, Techdirt reported.
The court noted cell phone searches are not regularly conducted in employment investigations and that Lattarulo’s partner was not subjected to a similar seizure.
“The presence of reasonable suspicion therefore does not categorically bar a finding of causation under Nieves,” Burroughs wrote, rejecting the government’s argument that reasonable suspicion alone defeats a retaliation claim.
What does the ruling mean for the phone data?
The injunction requires federal officials to preserve all copied cellphone data without accessing it while litigation continues, the ABA Journal reported. Lattarulo also sought documentation of the chain of custody for the information.
The court has not yet ruled on Fourth Amendment issues, saying those violations flow from the initial First Amendment violation.
Burroughs questioned whether the suspected crime — employment of unauthorized aliens under 8 U.S.C. § 1324a — qualifies as a “border-related crime” that would justify a warrantless advanced border search under the First Circuit’s Alasaad precedent. “It appears that the government seized on a fortuitous border crossing following a weekend vacation as an opportunity to search for evidence of a domestic crime it was already investigating,” she wrote.
Firm represents thousands in immigration cases
The firm represents “thousands of clients in active immigration proceedings,” court filings state. Lattarulo runs a popular Instagram account featuring videos of himself discussing “know-your-rights information about U.S. immigration matters,” which regularly “amasses hundreds of thousands of views,” according to the decision cited by Techdirt.

Government investigation targets law firm hiring
Homeland Security Investigations is examining whether Georges Cote LLP employs workers not authorized to work in the United States, according to FindLaw.
The firm represents “thousands of clients in active immigration proceedings,” court filings state.
Court blocks search of seized phone data
On November 13, Judge Burroughs issued an injunction requiring federal officials to preserve all copied cellphone data without accessing it while litigation continues, the ABA Journal reported. The government has claimed the seizure was part of the HSI employment investigation, but the court found no evidence that cell phones are routinely searched in such cases. Lattarulo also sought documentation of the chain of custody for the information on his phone.
The court has not yet ruled on Fourth Amendment issues, saying those violations flow from the initial First Amendment violation. “It appears that the government seized on a fortuitous border crossing following a weekend vacation as an opportunity to search for evidence of a domestic crime it was already investigating,” she wrote.
Government’s investigative timeline
Cote’s practice focuses on personal injury, not immigration, FindLaw reported.