Witness Recants Doc Traces How False Testimony Stole Three Lives
“You might want some tissues if you have some tissues,” director Dawn Porter warned the audience before the premiere of her documentary When A Witness Recants.
The film debuted in the Premieres section of the 2026 Sundance Film Festival at the Library Center Theatre in Park City. Executive produced by author Ta-Nehisi Coates, the project traces the 1983 murder of 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett inside Harlem Park Junior High, a Baltimore public school.
The crime caused widespread alarm in the community and led to the wrongful convictions of Andrew Stewart, Ransom Watkins, and Alfred Chestnut. The three Black teenagers from Coates’ neighborhood spent 36 years behind bars after police used coerced testimony to secure their convictions.
HBO Documentary Films will distribute the project, which charts the arc from the men’s youth in 1980s Baltimore to the decades they lost in prison. Their eventual exoneration followed the release of concealed police reports.
The documentary also centers on Ron Bishop and Edward Capers, two of the child witnesses whose fabricated testimony sealed the convictions. Based on a story by Jennifer Gonnerman for The New Yorker, the film features graphic animations by Dawud Anyabwile recreating the events.
Following the screening, the audience gave the film a standing ovation as Watkins, Chestnut, Stewart, and Porter took the stage. “When we came in to interview these gentlemen, we did not know how they would feel,” Porter told the theater.
“I’m thankful for HBO for putting this film together for all three of us and our family,” Chestnut said. “HBO has given us back our dignity.”
Stewart described the ongoing difficulties of adjusting to freedom after decades behind bars. “I’m not gonna sugar coat, try to make things sound good. It ain’t good. It’s hard. We’re still behind, we’re struggling in life every day,” Stewart said.
Watkins urged viewers to push for systemic changes to prevent similar miscarriages of justice. “What I want people to get from this is that the next generation shouldn’t have to go through this,” Watkins said.
Donald Kincaid, the former Baltimore Police Department lead investigator, and trial judge Robert Bell did not agree to be interviewed for the film. Kincaid coerced Bishop and Capers into giving false testimony by threatening them with violence and imprisonment.
Marilyn Mosby, the former State’s Attorney for Baltimore who helped secure the exoneration, spoke during a post-screening Q&A about local elections and prosecutorial accountability. “Prosecutors are one of the most important stakeholders in the criminal justice system,” Mosby said.
Porter previously brought Luther: Never Too Much to the 2024 Sundance Film Festival. When A Witness Recants marks her return to the festival.
Disclaimer: The views and cultural analyses presented in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Information regarding legal disputes or financial data is based on available public records.
Keep reading