Why Is the World Still Counting on Unproven Carbon Capture Technology?
Global climate policies and product labels rely on carbon capture technology that has built its projections on thin evidence and flawed assumptions, ProPublica reported.
- After three decades of development, only 12 large-scale geologic storage projects have ever been built, and at least seven have underperformed or failed.
- Last year, the world buried less carbon dioxide underground than a single large power plant emits annually.
- Climate models calculate up to a 92% success rate for capturing carbon, despite real capture rates running far lower.
World leaders and negotiators gathered in Antalya, Turkey, over a two-week span for the United Nations annual flagship climate summit to hash out global commitments to curb warming. Airline booking screens, shipping boxes, electronics, and grocery aisles display labels such as “carbon neutral,” “net zero,” and “climate pledge friendly.” These promises rest on the premise that companies and countries can keep burning fossil fuels while capturing the pollution and locking it away.
At the oil industry’s prodding, the United Nations has endorsed the idea that carbon capture and storage, or CCS, can work at a massive scale, IW Post reported. A central foundation of these negotiations is the expectation of burying billions of tons of carbon dioxide a year within just a couple of decades.
Climate policy stakes its success on a technology that remains largely unproven because economic and environmental simulations have already presumed it will work. ProPublica and Drilled investigated how the world came to rely on these models, speaking to more than 100 experts, including model builders.
Unlike scientists who rely on public, peer-reviewed studies, modelers are not required to document every assumption in their simulations. When ProPublica tracked down the leaders of the world’s three most influential climate models in the Netherlands, Germany, and Austria, they found that the simulations assume carbon capture is easy and efficient, Khan List reported.

The models factor in incentives like carbon taxes and government subsidies, calculating success rates as high as 92%.
Climate models also assume the Earth is a bottomless geologic landfill, a cue taken from a rosy 2005 United Nations report written at the behest of Saudi Arabia and allied petrostates.
A paper published last year in the journal Nature warned that the Earth’s capacity to absorb CCS could run out as soon as early next century once planners rule out pumping gas beneath cities, earthquake zones, and deep ocean floors. Riahi conceded that while his model presumes the Earth’s capacity is literally infinite, the real potential may be smaller.

“If a country is not willing to do that, I don’t see how they would be willing to” pay for carbon dioxide removal, said Jessica Strefler, who leads the German model, when asked if future generations will willingly pay big bucks to suck carbon out of the air.