Steelers Face Dilemma: Trade Star Linebacker?

Future of T.J. Watt Hinges on Contract Talks and Team Strategy

The Pittsburgh Steelers are at a crossroads. A looming contract impasse with star linebacker T.J. Watt, coupled with recent acquisitions, has cast doubt on his long-term future with the team. The Steelers’ actions this offseason suggest an uncertain path forward for a franchise cornerstone.

Uncertainty Looms for Watt

The Steelers have reportedly signaled they have “no intention” of trading Watt. However, that phrase is often a harbinger of a deal. The team is far apart from Watt on a new agreement. He is ready for any outcome and not afraid to push the issue.

…original tweet embed code…

“Could that push him out of Pittsburgh? In an offseason that has been all about upgrading a one-and-done (at best) roster, removing Watt won’t do much to deliver the franchise’s first playoff win since 2016 — one year before he arrived via round one.”

— Source Citation, if available

The Steelers must decide whether to trade him for immediate help or stockpile draft picks to secure a quarterback in the 2026 draft. Trading a star player can backfire if not handled correctly; for example, the Browns’ trade for Deshaun Watson has led to uncertainty (ESPN, 2024).

Strategic Implications

The Steelers have demonstrated significant urgency this offseason, investing heavily in players. If they are unwilling to match the level of contract other teams are giving to players like Myles Garrett, the best option could be to trade Watt to a team that will.

Ultimately, the Steelers’ choice will impact their ability to compete. The move could define the franchise for years. However, the situation with Watt will influence the club’s path for the coming seasons.