Weighing the Risk: Why Young Adults Skip Health Insurance Amid Rising ACA Premiums
“Bad things can happen that you aren’t ready for,” said Cynthia Cox, director of the Program on the Affordable Care Act at KFF, as open enrollment runs toward its January 15 close on the federal marketplace.
Behind her warning sits a fast-rising bill: for the second year in a row, monthly premiums for ACA health insurance have shot up, and young, healthy adults are weighing whether to simply go without.
That calculation is exactly what John O’Connell and Isabelle Davenport made this spring. The married couple quit their jobs to hike the Pacific Crest Trail and skipped the most expensive item on their safety checklist — health insurance.
O’Connell, 28, said temporary coverage through his former employer would have cost the couple $1,800 per month, so they opted out. They knew they would be uninsured only a few months, until O’Connell started medical school in the fall, and they considered themselves healthy.
They kept the decision from Davenport’s parents. “They would not have been OK with it,” O’Connell said. “They would have viewed it as, you know, irresponsible.”
The bet, in their case, paid off. Davenport developed an infection on the hike and needed an antibiotic, but a telehealth visit and an online pharmacy got her the medication cheaply — less, in total, than the couple would have paid for coverage.
KFF research shows adults under 35 were already more likely to be uninsured than other age groups even before the recent premium hikes, so the couple’s logic is hardly rare.
The math pushing the young out
The economics behind the exits are layered. When the federal tax penalty for being uninsured ended, many healthy people dropped their insurance, leaving insurers with a customer pool more likely to need care — which, Cox said, contributed to rising premiums. Costs worsened after some federal subsidies for the ACA marketplace expired last year, and about 1 in 10 marketplace enrollees dropped their coverage after that.
Health policy experts fear the cycle — higher costs driving out healthier customers, driving costs higher still — could end in a “death spiral” in which insurers no longer want to participate in the ACA marketplace at all. For now, Cox said, the remaining federal subsidies are keeping that spiral at bay.
“But it’s going to be harder and harder for people who don’t get a subsidy to afford to keep their coverage,” Cox said.”
That squeeze lands hardest on the group least likely to buy in. Open enrollment — the annual window when anyone can buy coverage on the Affordable Care Act marketplace — is the moment the decision gets made, and Cox encouraged those on the fence to do their research before the January 15 deadline rather than assume coverage is unaffordable, since federal subsidies may bring the cost down.
Care without coverage, bill by bill
Going without insurance does not mean going without care, Cox said — but finding affordable options takes work. Price transparency tools can show how much a service costs before a patient gets it. Her guidance for the uninsured:
- Treat the emergency room as a last resort. ERs must treat patients regardless of insurance status, but the bill can still be steep.
- Consider alternatives such as telemedicine, a federally qualified health center, a community clinic, or urgent care, depending on the medical need.
- Keep medical bills off credit cards, which carry high interest rates. “That’s essentially like taking out a high-interest loan,” Cox said.
- Call the hospital or doctor’s billing department to ask about payment plans or financial assistance programs, often called charity care.
- Seek out nonprofits, community organizations, and charitable programs that may help cover medical expenses, especially for a specific diagnosis like cancer.
A handful of states still penalize residents for lacking coverage; the federal penalty is gone. The result, in Cox’s account, is a marketplace thinner on healthy customers and pricier for everyone who stays.
Cox’s employer has a history tangled up with American health care. KFF began in 1948 as the Kaiser Family Foundation, founded by industrialist Henry J. Kaiser, and was once a major shareholder in Kaiser Industries — owning 32 percent of the company at its 1977 dissolution — before cutting financial ties with the Kaiser companies by 1985.
Despite the shared name, it has no affiliation with Kaiser Permanente. Since 2010, the nonprofit has run consumer resources for the Affordable Care Act itself, including a calculator for estimating coverage costs, and its newsroom was a Pulitzer Prize finalist in both 2020 and 2024 for investigative reporting on benefit clawbacks and hospital bill collection.
O’Connell and Davenport’s gamble ended cleanly, but Cox’s warning frames the risk for everyone tempted to follow them: a sudden illness or emergency can cost hundreds, thousands, even tens of thousands of dollars. The next dated decision point on the record is January 15, when open enrollment closes on the federal ACA marketplace.