US Proposes Ukraine Cede Donbas for NATO Membership as Envoys Meet in Berlin
US envoys proposed that Ukraine hand back the Donbas territory it still controls in return for NATO membership, President Volodymyr Zelensky said, and US, Ukrainian and European envoys will gather in Berlin today to work through outstanding questions before the next round of talks with Russia.
The idea surfaced after US-brokered talks in Abu Dhabi. The US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff raised the matter with Zelensky face to face, and then sat down with him again on their own following the Abu Dhabi negotiations.
Zelensky addressed reporters on Friday after trips to Denmark and Ireland, where he held meetings with European leaders in the wake of two days of US-brokered Ukraine-Russia talks in Abu Dhabi. The meeting was at Casement Aerodrome, an Irish military airport.
“The Americans raised a question: ‘What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?’ This was the first time this had been raised,” Zelensky said in the comments kept under embargo until Saturday.
The American envoys said that in Berlin, during our meetings tomorrow, they would give us a debrief on the talks the American President is currently holding in China. We will also be hearing from our partners currently in China. We and the Europeans have a clear, shared… pic.twitter.com/cOsudty2Mg
He said he would not decide alone. “If the American side confirms precisely this to us, together with other NATO partners, then I will ask our Ukrainian society what it thinks: do we accept it or not? I have no right to make that decision on my own,” he said, according to the Kyiv Independent’s account of the briefing.
Why the trade-off satisfies no one
The pitch asks Ukraine to give up land its army still defends, in return for an alliance promise Moscow has spent fighting. Russia has called Ukrainian NATO membership a red line and demands “a harsh response” if Kyiv ever joins. Moscow also insists Ukraine cede sovereignty over the Donbas region, in addition to parts of Zaporizhia and Kherson provinces that Russia already occupies — more than the US proposal contemplates.
Zelensky opposes ceding territory and has ruled out neutrality, which would require changing the country’s constitution. “If Putin expects Ukraine’s neutrality to be enshrined, that’s not going to happen,” he said, as the Guardian quoted him.
Any deal would also need specifics Ukraine says it has not received. The security package being negotiated covers NATO and EU guarantees, a well-equipped Ukrainian army of sufficient size, along with weapons and funding secured for a defined period, plus a so-called Prosperity Plan, or Recovery Plan, supported by money from clearly identified sources.
Zelensky asked for security guarantees modeled on Article 5 of NATO’s founding treaty “as an absolute minimum.” Washington is now saying it could be something similar to Articles 4 and 5, he added. US officials described the proposal as bilateral security guarantees similar to those Israel has. Asked whether American soldiers would be deployed on Ukrainian soil under such guarantees, the U.S. answer was “No,” he said.
Important meeting of the Ukraine Defence Contact Group. #NATO Allies are delivering – with announcements today of more air defence, missiles, ammunition & drones. Allies have also pledged $100s of millions more for PURL. We need to keep up our support to bring this war to a just… pic.twitter.com/PAUtJhW48
NATO’s position is that Ukraine belongs in the alliance eventually, as long as members consent and Kyiv fulfils the required criteria. Trump told Fox News in August 2025 that Ukraine would "not be a part of NATO," a shift from his earlier stance, Newsweek reported.
Europe’s sudden seat at the table
Kushner also told reporters that Putin has agreed to include Europe in peace negotiations. “We cannot conclude this deal without the Europeans being at the table,” he said.
US has floated Ukraine ceding Donbas for Nato membership, Zelensky says https://t.co/fj066A0qoA
RTÉ’s analysis, published ahead of the Berlin meeting, treats the shift with scepticism.
The EU signalled its own posture this week
What RTÉ says the precedent warns
The RTÉ analysis argues the proposal collapses two unequal positions into one bargain. Russia is an aggressor state launching its aggression in 2014, and dramatically scaling it up in 2022. Its leader acted of his own free will, directing his country’s taxpayers’ money and giving up the lives of more than 400,000 of his fellow citizens to chase an unprovoked and needless chauvinist conquest.
The report also cautions that history offers a warning: from the 1938 Munich Agreement that stripped Czechoslovakia of its fortified Sudetenland defences, to the 1940 Moscow Peace Treaty, that forced Finland to cede a tenth of its territory, and the 1995 Dayton Accords, that froze Bosnia and Herzegovina into fragile and perennial dysfunction, hurrying into concessions does not merely damage sustainable peace, it destroys justice.
❝We are doing our part to ensure peace talks will be successful, and that we can finally bring this war to a just and lasting peace.❞@SecGenNATO welcomed strong Allied support for Ukraine, with hundreds of millions of dollars of additional support pledged to PURL and…
RTÉ reported.
Where the proposal stands
- US-mediated talks between Ukrainian and Russian representatives in Abu Dhabi end without breakthrough; Moscow rejects an energy-target ceasefire.
- Kushner and Witkoff attended the Abu Dhabi talks and then met with Putin and Zelenskyy separately; European leaders meet in Dublin the next day.
- Zelenskyy’s remarks are released; he said any deal would come “without any recognition of the occupied territories as Russian.”
- US, Ukrainian and European envoys gather in Berlin today to work through outstanding questions before the next round of talks with Russia.
- European Council summit.
Still open, and still disputed
No concrete written proposal exists. Zelensky said the details remain under discussion. Moscow has cast doubt over EU involvement; Kyiv doubts Moscow is negotiating in good faith. In a separate matter, Zelenskyy has charged that SpaceX has been untruthful about limits placed on Ukraine’s Starshield satellite system, arguing that the choice to introduce speed caps seems to be “political” rather than “technical”.
Families navigating the displacement, cross-border claims and legal questions this war generates can consult international humanitarian organisations and specialist international law practitioners handling territorial and reparations claims — a field the proposed international claims commission would reshape if a settlement holds.
The next test of whether Europe’s seat is real comes at the European Council summit.
The U. S. has floated the idea of Ukraine joining NATO in exchange for withdrawing from its eastern Donbas region as part of negotiations to end the war, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said yesterday. https://t.co/Om4Gf0FUZl
US peace envoys asked whether Ukraine would be willing to give up the Donbas region in the nation’s east to Russia in exchange for NATO membership, said President Volodymyr Zelenskyy https://t.co/ukoYegZm9Z