Two NJ Women Indicted for Staging Hoax Attack, Prosecutors Say
Two New Jersey women were indicted on Friday on federal charges of staging a violent, politically motivated attack that prosecutors now describe as a fabricated hoax.
The incident began on July 23, 2025. Moe called 911 to report that she and Greene—a former staffer for Republican Representative Jeff Van Drew—had been accosted by three armed men at a nature preserve in Egg Harbor Township, nbcnews.com reported. Moe told dispatchers the assailants threatened them while referencing Greene’s employment, according to theguardian.com.
When officers arrived, they found Greene in a wooded area with her hands and feet bound by black zip ties and her shirt pulled over her head, nytimes.com noted. She had sustained lacerations on her face, neck, and chest. The words “TRUMP WHORE” were written on her stomach, and a message on her back labeled her former boss a racist.
Investigators later determined the injuries were not the result of an assault. According to the-independent.com, Greene allegedly paid a Pennsylvania body scarification artist $500 to cut the designs into her skin.
Evidence gathered by authorities pointed to a coordinated effort. Police recovered zip ties from Greene’s Maserati that matched those used to bind her, and Moe’s cellphone showed a search for “zip ties near me” two days before the reported event, theguardian.com reported. While Greene initially maintained the story to FBI agents, the indictment alleges the entire scene was staged.
“I’m just praying for her,” he said, according to nbcnews.com.
“Wish her the very best. I don't know anything more than you all do and we never would interfere with an investigation,” Van Drew said.
“Wish her the very best,” Drew said.
Greene was previously charged in a federal complaint last year and was released on a $200,000 unsecured bond, theguardian.com reported. Moe made her first appearance in federal court on Thursday. Each woman faces a maximum penalty of five years in prison and a $250,000 fine for the charges.

Details of the staged physical scene
Federal prosecutors allege that Natalie Greene orchestrated the elaborate scene by paying a body scarification artist $500 to carve permanent designs into her skin. According to the indictment, the procedure involved deliberately cutting her face, neck, upper chest, and shoulder to create lasting marks.
After the procedure, Greene reportedly met Anamaria Moe in South Jersey to finalize the hoax. Prosecutors claim the pair used a black marker to write “Trump W****” across Greene’s stomach and a message labeling her former boss as racist on her back.
Evidence of premeditated deception
Law enforcement officials found strong evidence showing the incident was planned well in advance. Investigators found black zip ties inside Greene’s Maserati on the night of the report that matched those used to bind her limbs, and forensic analysis of Moe’s cellphone revealed a search for “zip ties near me” conducted two days before the event.
Following the discovery of the scene, Greene maintained her account during multiple interviews with local police and FBI agents, claiming she had been held down and threatened by men with a gun. The indictment notes that Greene is also charged with making false statements and lying to federal investigators regarding these events.
Jeff Van Drew has served as the U.S. representative for New Jersey’s 2nd congressional district since 2019, according to his biography. He was first elected as a Democrat in 2018 but switched to the Republican Party in 2020 after opposing the first impeachment of Donald Trump.
Before entering Congress, Van Drew held a long career in state and local government, including service in the New Jersey General Assembly from 2002 to 2008 and the New Jersey Senate from 2008 to 2018, as well as roles as Mayor of Dennis Township and Cape May County Freeholder.
The motive for the staged attack remains unclear, as court documents do not specify why the women orchestrated the event. Lawyers for both women did not respond to requests for comment on Sunday, nytimes.com reported.