Overtourism sparks Clash: TUI and Airbnb Trade Blame
Europe’s tourism sector is embroiled in a heated dispute, with TUI, the continent’s largest travel operator, refuting claims made by Airbnb that hotels are the primary cause of “overtourism.” TUI contends that short-term home rental companies bear a important portion of the blame as protests intensify across Europe’s most visited destinations.
Tourism Industry Tensions Rise Amidst Protests
Fueled by post-pandemic travel surges, tensions are escalating between tourism rivals as local communities voice their discontent.Protests have erupted in cities like Barcelona, palma de Mallorca, Venice, Amsterdam, and Santorini, decrying overcrowding, soaring housing costs, and disruptive tourist behavior. These demonstrations underscore a growing frustration with the impacts of unchecked tourism growth.
Authorities are increasingly targeting the booming short-term rental sector, dominated by platforms like Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com, in an effort to mitigate the problems. These actions reflect a growing recognition of the need to regulate the industry and address the concerns of local residents.
Did You Know? According to a 2023 report by the European Environment agency,tourism accounts for approximately 8% of the EU’s total greenhouse gas emissions,highlighting the environmental impact of the sector.
Airbnb Defends Its Role, Points Finger at Hotels
Theo Yedinsky, vice-president for public policy at Airbnb, argues that the company is unfairly targeted and used as a “scapegoat” by local authorities and protesters. Yedinsky told the Financial Times that hotels are the real drivers of overtourism, especially in city centers. He believes that focusing solely on short-term rentals is an inadequate solution to a multifaceted problem.
TUI Counters Airbnb’s Claims
Alexander Panczuk, group director of policy and reputation at TUI, firmly rejects Airbnb’s scapegoat claim. He asserts that the root cause of the protests lies in the rising cost of living, particularly housing, which is directly influenced by the secondary home market and short-term leases. Panczuk emphasizes that TUI’s operations are not concentrated in the destinations experiencing the most acute conflicts between tourists and residents.
“It is indeed not scapegoating, it is a very neutral analysis of the problem,” Panczuk stated, highlighting the importance of addressing the underlying economic factors driving the unrest.
Pro Tip: When planning your trip, consider visiting destinations during the off-season to avoid crowds and support local economies in a more enduring way.
Government Intervention and regulatory Measures
Several European governments have taken decisive action to regulate short-term rentals. Spain’s government recently mandated Airbnb to remove nearly 66,000 listings from its platform. Portugal has suspended new short-term rental licenses in Lisbon, and Greece has implemented a one-year ban on new short-term rental registrations in Athens. These measures signal a growing trend toward stricter oversight of the short-term rental market.
Hotel Industry Calls for Level Playing Field
Hotrec, the European hotel industry’s lobby group, emphasizes that the hotel sector is heavily regulated to align with tourism capacity. The organization argues that services like Airbnb should be subject to the same regulatory standards to ensure fair competition and responsible tourism practices.
According to Eurostat data, hotels accounted for 63% of overnight visitors in europe last year, while apartments, vacation rentals, and other short-term rentals made up 24%, and campsites 13%. While hotel overnight stays increased by less than 4% year-on-year in 2024, the short let market surged by 8%, an increase of 57 million.
Data Highlights the Shift in Accommodation Preferences
| Accommodation Type | percentage of Overnight Visitors (2023) | Year-on-Year Growth (2024) |
|---|---|---|
| Hotels | 63% | < 4% |
| Apartments/Vacation Rentals | 24% | 8% |
| Campsites | 13% | N/A |
Airbnb Defends Its Impact
Yedinsky maintains that government targeting of services like Airbnb has not improved the situation as the core issues do not originate from short-term rentals. He suggests that local authorities should focus on broader solutions,such as increasing housing construction and managing hotel progress.
Citing Barcelona as an exmaple, Yedinsky argues that the mayor needs to address hotel construction and overall housing availability, rather than solely focusing on short-term rentals. He believes that targeting a small fraction of the problem will not yield significant improvements.
TUI Emphasizes Collaboration with Destination Partners
TUI, which facilitated bookings for 20.3 million customers last year, emphasizes its collaborative approach with destination partners. Panczuk states that local authorities are primarily focused on resolving their issues rather than engaging in blame-shifting. He highlights the ongoing discussions with ministers and members of parliament from various destinations regarding the challenges posed by holiday rentals.
“We talk a lot with our destination partners, ministers and mps from various destinations, and it is indeed mainly about [the issues] with holiday rentals. It is a topic that is discussed a lot because there is a real problem,” Panczuk said.
The Rise of Overtourism: A Deeper Look
overtourism is not a new phenomenon, but its impacts have become increasingly pronounced in recent years. Factors such as the rise of budget airlines, the proliferation of online booking platforms, and the growing popularity of experiential travel have contributed to the surge in tourist numbers. This influx of visitors can strain local infrastructure, drive up prices, and erode the cultural fabric of communities.
Sustainable tourism practices are essential to mitigating the negative effects of overtourism. These practices include promoting off-season travel, supporting local businesses, respecting local customs, and minimizing environmental impact. By adopting a more responsible approach to travel, we can help ensure that tourism benefits both visitors and host communities.
Frequently Asked Questions about Overtourism
- What are the main causes of overtourism?
- The main causes include the rise of budget airlines, the ease of online booking, and the increasing popularity of travel among a growing global middle class.
- How does overtourism affect local communities?
- Overtourism can lead to increased housing costs, strain on infrastructure, loss of cultural identity, and environmental degradation.
- What are some solutions to combat overtourism?
- Solutions include promoting off-season travel, investing in infrastructure, implementing tourism taxes, and educating tourists about responsible travel practices.
- What is the role of technology in addressing overtourism?
- Technology can be used to manage tourist flows, provide real-time information about crowding, and promote sustainable tourism options.
- How can travelers contribute to sustainable tourism?
- Travelers can contribute by choosing eco-kind accommodations, supporting local businesses, respecting local customs, and minimizing their environmental impact.
What steps can be taken to ensure tourism benefits both visitors and local communities? How can technology help manage tourist flows and promote sustainable travel options?
Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below. Subscribe to our newsletter for more updates on sustainable travel and global news!
