The History of Economic Warfare and Modern Russian Asset Freezes
Germany began World War I as the world’s third-biggest foreign investor, but by 1918, more than half of its foreign assets had been confiscated, according to a new history of economic warfare detailed by The Economist.
A. Mitchell Palmer served as the American Alien Property Custodian beginning six months after the United States joined the fight against Germany and Austria-Hungary in 1917. Tasked with seizing enemy-owned assets across the American economy, his office hoovered up factories, stocks, buildings, and patents.
Armies have often financed themselves by looting enemies, but because so many German-owned assets sat in Allied jurisdictions, authorities could seize them with little more than a stroke of a pen. As Mulder writes, Germany became the first country in the 20th century to have its assets expropriated on every continent.
Modern economic warfare mirrors these historical precedents following the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Western governments moved quickly to block roughly $60bn in Russian oligarchs’ assets, ranging from Saint-Tropez villas to Caribbean yachts. They also froze approximately $300bn worth of Russian central-bank reserves held in the West, with the majority kept at Euroclear, a Belgian depository.

Western leaders remain sharply divided over how to handle these immobilized funds. While allies auctioned off select seized luxury vessels and agreed in 2024 to use interest earnings from Russia’s reserves to extend a $50bn loan to Ukraine, legal and financial anxieties persist.
Belgium complained that confiscating the Euroclear reserves could leave the nation liable for damages equal to a third of its gross domestic product. Other officials expressed deep concern regarding Europe’s reputation as a bastion of strong property rights, which could deter future foreign investment.
“start breaking the international legal order,” warned Christine Lagarde, the head of the European Central Bank, regarding the risks of seizing Russian assets.
Such debates trace back centuries as governmental confiscatory powers evolved alongside the formalization of property rights. Once states grew powerful enough to protect claims to property, they simultaneously acquired the legal mechanisms to abrogate them.
Seventeenth-century Dutch jurist Hugo Grotius argued that all societies formed to protect property rights, yet carved out an explicit exception. Sovereign rulers maintained the right of eminent domain, permitting the seizure of private property for the public good.
Political figures and legal theorists quickly adopted the concept, from the American Founding Fathers to Napoleon in post-revolutionary France. Because property rights generally support economic growth, observers frequently understate the historical role of confiscation in prosperous states.
Economic historians Douglass North and Barry Weingast argued in 1989 that Britain’s Glorious Revolution of 1688 brought on the elimination of confiscatory government. In practice, however, that power simply shifted from the monarchy to Parliament, which subsequently wielded it to redistribute land and raise funds for wars.
Roughly 83% of constitutions adopted between 1850 and 2008 enshrine the explicit right to expropriate property for the public good. During wartime, these powers expand dramatically into sweeping asset seizures, echoing the actions taken against foreign investors more than a century ago.